Table 5.
League tables of relative treatment effects for craving, negative affect, and cognitive control outcomes.
| Panel A. Craving symptoms, O1 | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Row-defining intervention | ME | AE | RSE | MBE | YME | CON |
| ME | — | |||||
| AE | 0.220 (−0.570, 1.000) | — | ||||
| RSE | 0.460 (−0.370, 1.300) | 0.250 (−0.460, 0.950) | — | |||
| MBE | 0.570 (−0.350, 1.490) | 0.350 (−0.500, 1.210) | 0.110 (−0.800, 1.020) | — | ||
| YME | 1.120 (−0.200, 2.440) | 0.900 (−0.350, 2.160) | 0.660 (−0.590, 1.900) | 0.550 (−0.720, 1.820) | — | |
| CON | 0.990 (0.350, 1.630) | 0.770 (0.290, 1.250) | 0.520 (−0.110, 1.160) | 0.420 (−0.300, 1.130) | −0.130 (−1.310, 1.040) | — |
| Panel B. Negative affect symptoms, O2 | ||||||
| Row-defining intervention | AE | ME | YME | MBE | RSE | CON |
| AE | — | |||||
| ME | 0.330 (−0.700, 1.370) | — | ||||
| YME | 0.360 (−0.740, 1.460) | 0.020 (−1.240, 1.290) | — | |||
| MBE | 0.810 (−0.150, 1.770) | 0.470 (−0.620, 1.560) | 0.450 (−0.710, 1.600) | — | ||
| RSE | 1.130 (0.110, 2.150) | 0.790 (−0.430, 2.010) | 0.770 (−0.480, 2.020) | 0.320 (−0.750, 1.390) | — | |
| CON | 1.230 (0.520, 1.940) | 0.890 (0.010, 1.780) | 0.870 (−0.040, 1.790) | 0.420 (−0.290, 1.140) | 0.100 (−0.770, 0.970) | — |
| Panel C. Cognitive control function, O3 | ||||||
| Row-defining intervention | AE | RSE | MBE | YME | ME | CON |
| AE | — | |||||
| RSE | 0.760 (−2.780, 4.300) | — | ||||
| MBE | 0.890 (−4.720, 6.490) | 0.130 (−5.450, 5.700) | — | |||
| YME | 1.490 (−3.200, 6.180) | 0.730 (−4.660, 6.110) | 0.600 (−6.170, 7.370) | — | ||
| ME | 2.240 (−2.120, 6.610) | 1.480 (−3.190, 6.150) | 1.360 (−4.460, 7.170) | 0.750 (−4.920, 6.430) | — | |
| CON | 2.510 (−0.020, 5.040) | 1.750 (−1.520, 5.010) | 1.620 (−3.570, 6.820) | 1.020 (−3.500, 5.540) | 0.270 (−3.760, 4.290) | — |