Table 3.
Smile task quality checklist.
| Rule/issue | Penalty | ||
| Idle duration | |||
|
|
Idle >5 s before or after the task | 1 point | |
|
|
Idle ≥5 s between smiles | 2 points | |
| Background contrast and blurriness | |||
|
|
Dark/low-contrast background or blurry video, but face remains clearly visible | 1 point | |
|
|
Face visibility impaired (unclear face) | 2 points | |
| Multiple people in frame | |||
|
|
Photos/pictures of other people visible in background | 1 point | |
|
|
Another person’s face appears in the recording frame | 2 points | |
| Eyeglasses | |||
|
|
No glare or negligible glare | OK | |
|
|
Glare present, eyes remain partially visible | 1 point | |
|
|
Glare severely obstructs visibility of either eye | 2 points | |
| Smile count | |||
|
|
Exactly 3 smiles | OK | |
|
|
4 or 5 smiles | 1 point | |
|
|
<3 or >5 smiles | 2 points | |
| Expression ambiguity | |||
|
|
Smile resembles laughter or executed too quickly | 1 point | |
| Body movement | |||
|
|
Multiple head/body movements during smiles, but head always in the frame | 1 point | |
|
|
Head leaves the frame during the task | 2 points | |
| Distance from camera | |||
|
|
Head-and-shoulders (headshot) framing | OK | |
|
|
Waist visible in frame | 1 point | |
|
|
Lower body (eg, knees) visible; too far from camera | 2 points | |
| Noncompliance (any of the following) | |||
|
|
No smile-task recording; recorded on phone/tablet (instructed to use computer/laptop); face not fully visible; unstable/shaky camera; not forward-facing (bad angle); participant speaks during task | 2 points | |