Table 1. Description of the studies.
DRI: Disability Rating Index ; LBP: low back pain; LPP: Lumbopelvic pain; NRS: Numeric Rating Scale; ODI: Oswestry Disability Index; PGP: Pelvic Girdle Pain; PGQ: Pelvic Girdle Questionnaire; QBPDS: Quebec Back Pain Disability scale; RMDQ: Roland Morris Disability Questionnaire; SF: Short Form Health Survey; VAS: Visual Analogue Scale
a Not used in the analyses.
b The values of patients with LBP and PGP were summed and referred to as LPP in the analyses.
c Not used in the analyses because the data were not presented in detail.
| First author with year of publication | Country | Preventive (Prev) or therapeutic (Ther) | Most important inclusion criteria | Most important exclusion criteria | Interventions in the experimental group | Intervention in the control group as worded by the authors | Measurements |
| Backhausen 2017 [10] | Denmark | Prev | age >18 years; 20 weeks pregnant; singleton pregnancy; healthy | BMI>29; severe PGP; abuse problems | exercises in a swimming pool; twice a week for 12 weeks; supervised in the first contact | standard prenatal care | - pain intensity on an NRS - RMDQ - proportion of women with LPP - proportion of women on sick leave |
| Bandpei 2010 [2] | Iran | Ther | 12-22 weeks pregnant; healthy | specific causes of low back pain | exercises to strengthen the abdominal and back muscles; daily for 12 weeks; supervised in the first contact; ergonomic advice | no intervention | - pain intensity on a VAS - ODI |
| Barbier 2023 [11] | France | Ther | 15-32 weeks pregnant; singleton pregnancy; healthy; BMI< 32 kg/m2 | specific causes of low back pain; high-risk pregnancy | stretching and contraction of paravertebral muscles; 20-30 minutes, 2-3 times a week for two months | advice on ergonomics and activities | - pain intensity on an NRS - physical component SF-12 |
| Eggen 2012 [6] | Norway | Prev | age 18-40 years; 20 weeks pregnant; singleton pregnancy; healthy | high-risk pregnancy | aerobics, activation of stabilizing muscles and pelvic floor; once a week in classes supervised and daily at home 16-20 weeks; ergonomic advice | standard care | - pain intensity morning on an NRSa - pain intensity evening on an NRS - RMDQ - physical component SF-8a - proportion of women with PGPb - proportion of women with LBPb |
| Field 2012 [12] | USA | Ther | age 18-40 years; 18-22 weeks pregnant; singleton pregnancy; depressed; otherwise, healthy | drug abuse; other psychiatric condition than depression | yoga; 20 minutes in classes, once a week, from inclusion to week 32 | standard prenatal care | - pain intensity on an NRS |
| Figueira 2014 [13] | Brazil | Prev | age >18 years; 20-31 weeks pregnant; healthy | high-risk pregnancy | static flexibility exercises 45 minutes; twice a week for 9 weeks | conventional medical treatment with postural guidelines for LBP prevention | - pain intensity on a VAS |
| Figueira 2014 [13] | Brazil | Ther | |||||
| Filipec 2020 [14] | Croatia | Ther | age 25-45 years; 10-34 weeks pregnant | other causes of back pain | pelvic tilt exercises, gluteus contractions and active hip flexion; 20 minutes two times a week | the control group continued to adhere to their regular life habits. | - pain intensity on a VAS - QBPDS |
| Garshasbi 2005 [15] | Iran | Prev | age 20-28 years; 17-22 weeks pregnant; healthy; nulliparous; housewife; high school graduated | severe back pain before pregnancy; orthopedic diseases; | strengthening of trunk and hip muscles; cardiovascular fitness; three times a week for 12 weeks; | not mentioned | - Pain intensity with a modified QBPDS |
| Gil 2011 [16] | Brazil | Ther | age 18-40 years; 20-25 weeks pregnant; nulliparous | pathology of the spine; obstetric or gynecologic pathology | stretching by means of Global Postural Re-education; 40 minutes, once a week for 8 weeks | routine prenatal care | - pain intensity with a VAS - RMDQ 24 |
| Haakstad 2015 [3] | Norway | Prev | <24 weeks pregnant; singleton pregnancy; nulliparous; healthy; sedentary | inability to attend weekly exercise classes; insufficient knowledge of the Norwegian language | as control group and aerobic dance with focus on endurance, strength of stabilizing muscles and pelvic floor; 2-3 times a week for 12 weeks; supervised; ergonomic advice | usual prenatal care | - proportion of women with PGP - proportion of women with LBPb - questions about influence of LPP on activities of daily life (Y/N) and about influence of LPP on physical activity (Y/N)a |
| Kashanian 2009 [17] | Iran | Prev | age 20-30 years; 16 weeks pregnant; nulliparous; healthy | drug abuse | as control group and relaxation and strengthening of various muscles of trunk, shoulder and hips; three times a week for 8 weeks | routine prenatal care | - pain intensity (method not mentioned) |
| Keskin 2012 [18] | Turkey | Ther | >32 weeks pregnant | other causes of back or pelvic pain | pelvic tilt exercises, stretching muscles of lower extremity, isometric abdominal contractions and posture exercises; two times a day for 3 weeks | not mentioned | - pain intensity with a VAS - RMDQ 24 |
| Kihlstrand 1999 [19] | Sweden | Prev | <19 weeks pregnant; healthy | epilepsy; insufficient knowledge of the Swedish language | water-based exercises; once a week for 12-17 weeks; supervised | not mentioned | - pain intensity at its worst on a VASc - pain intensity at its mildest on a VASc - pain intensity ‘just now’ on a VASc - proportion of women with LPP - proportion of women on sick leave because of LPP |
| Kluge 2011 [20] | South Africa | Ther | age 20-40 years; 16-24 weeks pregnant | pathology of the spine; obstetric or gynecologic pathology | exercises to strengthen and activate transverse abdominal muscles, pelvic floor, hip muscles and quadriceps; daily at home and every 2 weeks 30-45 minutes in supervised classes for 10 weeks | basic care and information about ergonomics and correct posture | - pain intensity on NRS 0-60 - Likert-Modified RMDQ 0-144 |
| Knudsen 2024 [21] | Denmark | Prev | <15 weeks pregnant; sedentary; healthy | as control group and exercises in gym or swimming pool; supervised; once a week from inclusion to delivery | standard prenatal care | - pain intensity - physical component SF-36 - proportion of women on sick leave with medical certificate - proportion of women on sickness absence without medical certificatea - proportion of women with LPP | |
| Kordi 2013 [22] | Iran | Ther | age <40 years; 20-32 weeks pregnant; singleton pregnancy; healthy; positive tests for PGP | contraindications to exercise in pregnancy | as control group and hip, trunk, and pelvic floor muscles, two times a day, three times a week for 6 weeks | general information | - pain intensity on a VAS - ODI |
| Mamipour 2023 [23] | Iran | Ther | age >18 years; 17-18 weeks pregnant; nulliparous; healthy; LPP for more than one week | history of LPP before pregnancy | as control group and activating pelvic floor and deep abdominal muscles; three times a week for 10 weeks; in supervised groups and at home; | standard antenatal care and customary information | - pain intensity on a VAS - ODI |
| Martins 2005 [24] | Brazil | Ther | >12 weeks pregnancy; singleton pregnancy; living in Paulínia | contraindication for training; already treated with physiotherapy | stretching by means of Global Postural Re-education; one hour, once a week for 8 weeks | treatment according to medical guidelines | - pain intensity on a VAS |
| Miquelutti 2013 [25] | Brazil | Prev | age 16-40 years; ≥18 weeks pregnant; singleton pregnancy; healthy | stretching of various muscle groups, activating the pelvic floor and transverse abdominal muscles; aerobics; breathing techniques and relaxation exercises in preparation for childbirth; daily at home and supervised every 1-4 weeks | routine of prenatal care | - proportion of women with LPP | |
| Mirmolaei 2018 [4] | Iran | Ther | age 18-35 years; 17-22 weeks pregnant; singleton pregnancy; healthy | contraindications to exercise | as control group and ergonomic advice; stretching and strengthening muscles; 10 times a day for 12 weeks at home | routine prenatal care | - pain intensity on a VAS - ODI |
| Mørkved 2007 [5] | Norway | Prev | 18 weeks pregnant; nulliparous; healthy | as control group and aerobic training, activation of stabilizing muscles and pelvic floor; weekly training at home twice daily for 12 weeks | customary information and providing a pelvic belt | - DRI - proportion of women on sick leave - proportion of women with LPP | |
| Niaraki 2021 [26] | Iran | Ther | age 20-35 years; 20-26 weeks pregnant; singleton pregnancy; RMDQ 24 score ≥12; VAS Pain ≥4 | contraindications to exercise; known musculoskeletal, neurological, or psychiatric disorder; use of painkillers or fear of water | aerobics in water and stretching 60 minutes, three times a week for 2 months | standard prenatal care | - pain intensity with a VAS - RMDQ 24 |
| Nilsson 2005 [27] | Sweden | Ther | <35 weeks pregnant; three positive tests for PGP | positive tests for LBP | home exercises of muscle among hips and balance training; two times a week for 16 weeks; supervised in the first contact | customary information and providing a pelvic belt; availability to call a helpdesk. | - pain intensity on a VAS median - DRI |
| Nilsson 2005 [27] | Sweden | Ther | exercises for muscle strength and cardiovascular fitness two times a week for 16 weeks; all supervised | customary information and providing a pelvic belt; availability to call a helpdesk. | |||
| Ostgaard 1994 [28] | Sweden | Prev | 18 weeks pregnant; nulliparous; healthy | Supervised individual sessions with back school education and training: 5 sessions of 30 minutes and training at home three times a week; providing general information and ergonomic advice; half of the women with LPP were given a pelvic belt | according to the usual routines | - pain intensityc - proportion of women on sick leave - proportion of women with LPPc | |
| Ostgaard 1994 [28] | Sweden | Prev | supervised classes with back school education and training 2 sessions of 45 minutes; providing general information and ergonomic advice; half of the women with LPP were given a pelvic belt | according to the usual routines | |||
| Ozdemir 2015 [29] | Turkey | Ther | age >18 years; 20-35 weeks pregnant; sedentary lifestyle | severe low back and/or pelvic disease before pregnancy; using other treatments for low back or pelvic pain | stretching, strengthening, and loosening of spine muscles on a mattress or brisk walking; 30 minutes, three times a week for 4 weeks | usual care | - pain intensity with a VAS - ODI |
| Poděbradská 2019 [30] | Czech | Prev | end of second trimester or beginning of third trimester of pregnancy | exercises to reduce the pronation position of the feet; daily 10-15 minutes in the second trimester of the pregnancy | no specific exercises | - McGill Pain Questionnaire - Pregnancy Mobility Scale | |
| Ramezanpour 2018 [31] | Iran | Ther | age >24 years; 20-35 weeks pregnant; primigravida; singleton pregnancy; healthy | exercises before pregnancy | body balance three times a week for 12 weeks | usual care | - pain intensity on a VAS |
| Ramezanpour 2018 [31] | Iran | Ther | pelvic floor exercises; two times a day for 12 weeks | usual care | |||
| Ramezanpour 2018 [31] | Iran | Ther | body balance three times a week and pelvic floor exercises; two times a day for 12 weeks | usual care | |||
| Sedaghati 2007 [32] | Iran | Prev | not mentioned | contraindications to aerobics | supervised aerobics 60 min with accent on bicycling, 3 times a week | not mentioned | - pain intensity with a modified QBPDS |
| SklempeKokic 2017 [33] | Croatia | Prev | age 20-40 years; <30 weeks pregnant | contraindications for exercise, smoking, severe lumbopelvic pain before pregnancy | aerobics, brisk walking; resistance exercises of muscles in the lumbopelvic area, upper and lower limb, back extensors, pelvic floor and deep abdominal muscles; two times a week from inclusion to end of pregnancy | standard antenatal care | - pain intensity with an NRS - RMDQ 24 - PGQa |
| Sonmezer 2021 [34] | Turkey | Ther | age 20-35 years; 22-24 weeks pregnant; parity ≤3 | pre-pregnancy lumbar pain; contraindications for exercises | Pilates exercises 60 minutes; two times a week for 8 weeks | regular prenatal care | - pain intensity on a VAS - ODI |
| Stafne 2012 [35] | Norway | Prev | 18-22 weeks pregnant; singleton pregnancy; healthy | high-risk pregnancies | supervised aerobics; activation of stabilizing muscles and pelvic floor; 60 minutes once a week; providing ergonomic advice | standard antenatal care; providing general information | - pain intensity in the morninga - pain intensity in the evening - DRI - proportion of women on sick leave - proportion of women with LPP |
| Suputtidada 2002 [36] | Thailand | Ther | not mentioned | not mentioned | sitting pelvic tilt exercises; 4-10 repetitions per session, two times a day, five days per week, for 8 weeks | did not perform any exercise | - pain intensity on a VAS |
| Yildirim 2023 [37] | Turkey | Ther | age 18-40 years; 14-24 weeks pregnant; singleton pregnancy; healthy; VAS pain ≥2 | other cause of back pain; contraindications for exercises | pilates exercises; 60 minutes, two times a week for 12 weeks | usual prenatal care | - pain intensity on a VAS - RMDQ 24 |