TABLE 2.
A comparative literature review of related and present studies
| Present study | Castro Sousa et al. (2016) (5) | Iurato et al. (2001) (6) | Chavan et al. (2017) (7) | Dornhoffer (2003) (8) | Mundada and Jaiswal (1989) (9) | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sample size Mean age (years) M:F ratio Follow-up |
n = 50 26.7 (range 8–55 years) 26:24 19.2 months |
n = 153 – 85:68 – |
n = 181 39 years 6 months 90:91 2 years 7 months (range: 1–16 years) |
n = 50 36.4 years 29:21 – |
n = 636 30 years (range: 4–88 years) – 2.7 years (range: 3–7 years) |
n = 115 – – 1–13 years |
| Surgical technique | Notched cartilage + Incus interposition + Canal wall down Mastoidectomy with cavity obliteration | Autologous ossicle Cortical bone/cartilage titanium used as prosthesis |
Autologous/homologous body of the incus, head of the malleus, PORP used as prosthesis | Autologous INCUS in 40 (80%) cases, head of the malleus in 10 (20%) cases–used as ossiculoplast |
PORP: 252 cases TORP: 158 cases Mastoidectomy: 236 cases |
Tunnel between the outer perichondrium and the cartilage to accommodate the remnants of the Incus or handle of the malleus |
| Inclusion criteria | Austin group A | All patients with ossicular discontinuity | Austin-Kartush group A | Three groups of patients: Cholesteatoma, atelectasis, high-risk recurrent perforation |
_ | |
| Preoperative ABG (dB) | 29.4 dB ± 9.45 dB SD | 35.3 dB ± 10.6 dB SD | 26 dB ± 12 dB SD | 34.9 dB ± 10.15 dB SD | 25.7 dB ± 11.8 dB SD | |
| Postoperative ABG (dB) | 19.7 dB ± 10.28 dB SD | 14 dB ± 10.5 dB SD | 26 dB ± 12 dB SD | 12.92 dB ± 7.92 dB SD | 14.1 dB ± 9.5 dB SD | <20 dB in 74% of patients |
| P-value | <0.001 | <0.05 | Not significant | <0.001 | <0.05 | <0.01 |
| Remarks | With cholesteatoma 13(26%) cases, without cholesteatoma 37 (74%) cases |
With cholesteatoma 57 (37.1%) cases, without cholesteatoma-96 (63%) cases |
Perforation of tympanic graft in 13 (7.2%) cases after ossiculoplasty. (patients with extensive cholesteatoma excluded) | Patients with cholesteatoma excluded | Complications: 14 (2.2%) perforations, 21 (3.3%) revision surgery, 8(1.3%) recurrent cholesteatoma, 3 (0.5%) delayed facial palsy, complete recovery within 4–6 weeks after operation |
Cholesteatoma in 2(1.7%) cases, granulation in 26 (22.6%) cases, eroded INCUS in 73 (63.4%) cases |
ABG indicates air-bone gap; PORP, partial ossicular reconstruction prosthesis; TORP, total ossicular reconstruction prosthesis.