Skip to main content
. 2026 Aug 11;6(3):e095. doi: 10.1097/ONO.0000000000000095

TABLE 2.

A comparative literature review of related and present studies

Present study Castro Sousa et al. (2016) (5) Iurato et al. (2001) (6) Chavan et al. (2017) (7) Dornhoffer (2003) (8) Mundada and Jaiswal (1989) (9)
Sample size
Mean age (years)
M:F ratio
Follow-up
n = 50
26.7 (range 8–55 years)
26:24
19.2 months
n = 153
–
85:68
–
n = 181
39 years 6 months
90:91
2 years 7 months (range: 1–16 years)
n = 50
36.4 years
29:21
–
n = 636
30 years (range: 4–88 years)
–
2.7 years (range: 3–7 years)
n = 115
–
–
1–13 years
Surgical technique Notched cartilage + Incus interposition + Canal wall down Mastoidectomy with cavity obliteration Autologous ossicle
Cortical bone/cartilage titanium used as prosthesis
Autologous/homologous body of the incus, head of the malleus, PORP used as prosthesis Autologous INCUS in 40
(80%) cases, head of the malleus in 10 (20%) cases–used as ossiculoplast
PORP: 252 cases
TORP: 158 cases
Mastoidectomy: 236 cases
Tunnel between the outer perichondrium and the cartilage to accommodate the remnants of the Incus or handle of the malleus
Inclusion criteria Austin group A All patients with ossicular discontinuity Austin-Kartush group A Three groups of patients:
Cholesteatoma, atelectasis, high-risk recurrent perforation
_
Preoperative ABG (dB) 29.4 dB ± 9.45 dB SD 35.3 dB ± 10.6 dB SD 26 dB ± 12 dB SD 34.9 dB ± 10.15 dB SD 25.7 dB ± 11.8 dB SD
Postoperative ABG (dB) 19.7 dB ± 10.28 dB SD 14 dB ± 10.5 dB SD 26 dB ± 12 dB SD 12.92 dB ± 7.92 dB SD 14.1 dB ± 9.5 dB SD <20 dB in 74% of patients
P-value <0.001 <0.05 Not significant <0.001 <0.05 <0.01
Remarks With cholesteatoma 13(26%) cases,
without cholesteatoma 37 (74%) cases
With cholesteatoma 57 (37.1%) cases,
without cholesteatoma-96
(63%) cases
Perforation of tympanic graft in 13 (7.2%) cases after ossiculoplasty. (patients with extensive cholesteatoma excluded) Patients with cholesteatoma excluded Complications:
14 (2.2%) perforations, 21 (3.3%) revision surgery, 8(1.3%) recurrent cholesteatoma, 3 (0.5%) delayed facial palsy, complete recovery within 4–6 weeks after operation
Cholesteatoma in 2(1.7%) cases, granulation in 26 (22.6%) cases, eroded INCUS in 73 (63.4%) cases

ABG indicates air-bone gap; PORP, partial ossicular reconstruction prosthesis; TORP, total ossicular reconstruction prosthesis.