Table 2.
Comparison of consistency values within and between models
| Group | ChatGPT 5.2 | Gemini | DeepSeek | Test statistics | p x |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A | 100 (100: 100) / 19,5 a | 100 (83,33: 100) / 15,55 ab | 95,83 (58,33: 100) / 11,45 b | 6,912 | 0,032 |
| B | 100 (66,67: 100) / 15,75 | 100 (66,67: 100) / 16,35 | 100 (58,33: 100) / 14,4 | 0,367 | 0,832 |
| C | 100 (58,33: 100) / 13,65 | 100 (91,67: 100) / 18,35 | 100 (58,33: 100) / 14,5 | 2,676 | 0,262 |
| D | 100 (91,67: 100) / 16,65 ab | 100 (100: 100) / 18 a | 100 (83,33: 100) / 11,85 b | 6,412 | 0,041 |
| E | 95,83 (75: 100) / 14,45 | 100 (50: 100) / 15,75 | 100 (83,33: 100) / 16,3 | 0,3 | 0,861 |
| F | 100 (100: 100) / 18 a | 100 (100: 100) / 18 a | 95,83 (66,67: 100) / 10,5 b | 11,484 | 0,003 |
| Total | 100 (58,33: 100) / 94,94 a | 100 (50: 100) / 99,93 a | 100 (58,33: 100) / 76,63 b | 11,015 | 0,004 |
| Test statistics | 13,028 | 8,260 | 1,348 | ||
| p x | 0,023 | 0,143 | 0,930 |
x Kruskal–Wallis H test; median (minimum–maximum)
a–b No significant difference between language models sharing the same letter. Bold values indicate statistically significant differences (p < 0.05).