Table 2.
Reported methodological quality of included randomised clinical trials assessing effects of hepatitis B vaccines and immunoglobulin for newborn infants of mothers positive for hepatitis B surface antigen
Trial | Generation of allocation sequence | Allocation concealment | Blinding | Methodological quality |
---|---|---|---|---|
Assateerawatt 199323 | Adequate | Unclear | Not done | Low |
Beasley 19837,24 | Unclear | Unclear | Unclear | Low |
Beasley 198325 | Unclear | Unclear | Unclear | Low |
Farmer 198726 | Adequate | Unclear | Not done | Low |
Garcia 199227 | Unclear | Unclear | Unclear | Low |
Grosheide 199329 | Unclear | Adequate | Not done | Low |
Halliday 199230 | Adequate | Adequate | Adequate | High* |
Hieu 200231 | Adequate | Adequate | Not done | High* |
Ip 198932,33,54 | Unclear | Adequate | Adequate | High* |
Kang 199534 | Unclear | Unclear | Not done | Low |
Khukhlovich 199635 | Unclear | Unclear | Unclear | Low |
Kuru 199536 | Unclear | Unclear | Not reported | Low |
Lee 199537-39 | Unclear | Unclear | Not done | Low |
Liu 198740 | Unclear | Adequate | Adequate | High* |
Lo 198528,41 | Unclear | Unclear | Not done | Low |
Lolekha 200242 | Unclear | Unclear | Not done | Low |
Oon 198643 | Adequate | Unclear | Not done | Low |
Piazza 198544 | Adequate | Adequate | Unclear | High* |
Pongpipat 198645 | Unclear | Unclear | Not done | Low |
Pongpipat 198846 | Unclear | Unclear | Not done | Low |
Pongpipat 198947 | Unclear | Unclear | Not done | Low |
Poovorawan 199748,49 | Unclear | Unclear | Not done | Low |
Sehgal 199250,51 | Unclear | Unclear | Not done | Low |
Theppisai 198752 | Unclear | Unclear | Not done | Low |
Theppisai 199053 | Unclear | Unclear | Not done | Low |
Xu 199555-57 | Unclear | Unclear | Unclear | Low |
Yeoh 198658 | Unclear | Unclear | Not done | Low |
Zhu 198760 | Unclear | Unclear | Unclear | Low |
Zhu 199459 | Unclear | Unclear | Not done | Low |
Trials having low risk of bias.