Skip to main content
. 2006 Feb 11;332(7537):328–336. doi: 10.1136/bmj.38719.435833.7C

Table 2.

Reported methodological quality of included randomised clinical trials assessing effects of hepatitis B vaccines and immunoglobulin for newborn infants of mothers positive for hepatitis B surface antigen

Trial Generation of allocation sequence Allocation concealment Blinding Methodological quality
Assateerawatt 199323 Adequate Unclear Not done Low
Beasley 19837,24 Unclear Unclear Unclear Low
Beasley 198325 Unclear Unclear Unclear Low
Farmer 198726 Adequate Unclear Not done Low
Garcia 199227 Unclear Unclear Unclear Low
Grosheide 199329 Unclear Adequate Not done Low
Halliday 199230 Adequate Adequate Adequate High*
Hieu 200231 Adequate Adequate Not done High*
Ip 198932,33,54 Unclear Adequate Adequate High*
Kang 199534 Unclear Unclear Not done Low
Khukhlovich 199635 Unclear Unclear Unclear Low
Kuru 199536 Unclear Unclear Not reported Low
Lee 199537-39 Unclear Unclear Not done Low
Liu 198740 Unclear Adequate Adequate High*
Lo 198528,41 Unclear Unclear Not done Low
Lolekha 200242 Unclear Unclear Not done Low
Oon 198643 Adequate Unclear Not done Low
Piazza 198544 Adequate Adequate Unclear High*
Pongpipat 198645 Unclear Unclear Not done Low
Pongpipat 198846 Unclear Unclear Not done Low
Pongpipat 198947 Unclear Unclear Not done Low
Poovorawan 199748,49 Unclear Unclear Not done Low
Sehgal 199250,51 Unclear Unclear Not done Low
Theppisai 198752 Unclear Unclear Not done Low
Theppisai 199053 Unclear Unclear Not done Low
Xu 199555-57 Unclear Unclear Unclear Low
Yeoh 198658 Unclear Unclear Not done Low
Zhu 198760 Unclear Unclear Unclear Low
Zhu 199459 Unclear Unclear Not done Low
*

Trials having low risk of bias.