eTable. Overview of the most commonly used classification systems for periprosthetic fractures of the hip and knee*.
| Classification (Ref) | Location | Classification criteria | Types/categories | Therapeutic implications |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Vancouver
Classification (24) |
Femur (hip prosthesis) | Fracture location relative to the stem, implant stability, bone quality | A: trochanteric region (AG: greater trochanter; AL: lesser trochanter); B: at the level of the stem (B1: stable stem; B2: loose stem, good bone stock; B3: loose stem, poor bone stock); C: distal to the stem | International standard; the choice between internal fixation (B1, C) and revision arthroplasty (B2, B3) is based primarily on stem stability |
| Peterson-Lewallen
Classification (30) |
Acetabulum (hip prosthesis) | Acetabular cup stability | Type 1: stable cup; Type 2: unstable/ loosened cup | Simple dichotomy: type 1 often nonoperative or plate fixation; type 2 requires acetabular revision |
| Pascarella
Classification (28) |
Acetabulum (hip prosthesis) | Timing of fracture (intraoperative vs. postoperative), fracture morphology, acetabular cup stability | Multi-tiered classification with subtypes for intraoperative fractures during press-fit cup insertion, postoperative traumatic and stress-related fractures | Allows the formulation of differentiated treatment algorithms; also takes pelvic discontinuity into account |
| Lewis-Rorabeck
Classification (25) |
Distal femur (knee prosthesis) | Fracture displacement, implant stability | Type I: nondisplaced, implant stable;
Type II: displaced, implant stable; Type III: displaced, implant loose |
Widely used in clinical practice. type III requires revision arthroplasty (with distal femoral replacement where appropriate); types I and II are amenable to internal fixation |
| Su Classification (31) | Distal femur (knee prosthesis) | Location of the fracture line in relation to the femoral component | Type I: proximal to the anterior flange;
Type II: originating at the level of the anterior flange; Type III: distal to the anterior flange |
Supplementary to the Lewis-Rorabeck classification; clinically relevant when choosing between plate fixation and retrograde intramedullary nailing |
| Felix Classification (26) | Proximal tibia (knee prosthesis) | Anatomical location; status of tibial implant component (stable vs. loose) indicated by an additional letter | Type I: tibial plateau; Type II: adjacent to the tibial stem; Type III: distal to the prosthesis; Type IV: involves the tibial tubercle | Standard classification for tibial fractures. Implant stability determines choice between internal fixation and revision; type IV fractures require stabilization of the extensor mechanism |
| Ortiguera and Berry Classification (27) | Patella (knee prosthesis) | Stability of the patellar implant, integrity of the extensor mechanism | Type I: stable patellar implant, intact extensor mechanism; Type II: disrupted extensor mechanism; Type IIIa: loose patellar implant, good patellar bone stock; Type IIIb: loose patellar implant, poor patellar bone stock | Treatment ranges from nonoperative management (type I) to extensor mechanism reconstruction (type II) and component exchange (type III) |
| Keating
Classification (32) |
Patella (knee prosthesis) | Fracture morphology, component stability, extensor mechanism function | Type A: nondisplaced, stable; Type B: displaced, intact extensor mechanism; Type C: displaced, disrupted extensor mechanism | An alternative to the Ortiguera and Berry classification, with similar treatment implications |
| Unified Classification System UCS (29) | Applicable across different joints | Unified regimen comprising six types (A-F) based on fracture location, implant stability, bone stock, timing of the fracture | A: Apophyseal; B: Bed of implant; C: Clear of implant; D: Dividing the bone between two implants (interprosthetic fracture); E: Each of the two bones supporting a joint replacement; F: Facing and articulating with a hemiarthroplasty | Conceptual framework incorporating joint-specific classifications; in clinical routine practice, clinicians continue to rely primarily on the respective established classification systems |
All systems are based on the fundamental principle of incorporating fracture location, implant stability, and bone quality as variables to guide treatment. In clinical routine practice, clinicians rely primarily on joint-specific classification systems.
vs., versus