Table 3.
Involving current or former users of a mental health service as interviewers of recipients of the service (clients) in evaluating mental health services
Study
|
Users involved
|
Design of study
|
Measurement of clients' views of service
|
Significant differences between groups
|
---|---|---|---|---|
Clark, 1999, Canada9 | Four with severe mental disorder and prior psychiatric hospitalisation | Randomised controlled trial of user interviewers (n=60) and staff interviewers (n=60) | Extremely positive and negative responses and general satisfaction | Clients interviewed by user interviewers gave more extremely negative responses about services |
Polowczykl, 1993, USA16 | People with schizophrenia or affective disorder in remission | Comparative study of user interviewers (n=225) and staff interviewer (n=305) | Satisfaction score | Clients interviewed by user interviewers gave lower service satisfaction scores |