Skip to main content
. 2026 Oct 19;14:1961368. doi: 10.3389/fpubh.2026.1961368

Table 4.

GRADE assessment of the certainty of evidence.

Factors No. of included studies Study design Initial certainty Risk of bias Inconsistency Indirectness Imprecision Publication bias Upgrading factors Final certainty of evidence
Educational level 4 Cross-sectional Low Downgraded 1 level Not downgraded Not downgraded Not downgraded Unable to assess None identified Very low
Night shift frequency 2 Cross-sectional Low Downgraded 1 level Not downgraded Not downgraded Not downgraded Unable to assess None identified Very lowi
Employment type 3 Cross-sectional Low Downgraded 1 level Not downgraded Not downgraded Downgraded 1 level Unable to assess None identified Very low
Self-efficacy 3 Cross-sectional Low Downgraded 1 level Downgraded 1 level Not downgraded Downgraded 1 level Unable to assess None identified Very low
Professional identity 3 Cross-sectional Low Downgraded 1 level Downgraded 1 level Not downgraded Not downgraded Unable to assess None identified Very low
Perceived organizational support 3 Cross-sectional Low Downgraded 1 level Downgraded 1 level Not downgraded Downgraded 1 level Unable to assess None identified Very low
Empowering leadership 2 Cross-sectional Low Downgraded 1 level Downgraded 1 level Not downgraded Not downgraded Unable to assess None identified Very low