Table 2.
Quality Features of Articles Included for Review
Source | Randomized | Double- Blinded | Description of Dropouts | Design | Description of Allocation Concealment | Power Analysis | Intention to Treat |
Charles et al,12 2000 | Yes | Yes | Yes | RCT | Indeterminant | Yes | Yes |
Charles et al,13 1998 | Yes | Yes | Yes | RCT | Indeterminant | No | No |
Fontbonne et al,14 1996 | Yes | Yes | Yes | RCT | Indeterminant | Yes | Yes |
Guigliano et al,15 1993 | Yes | Yes | Yes | Crossover | Indeterminant | Yes | No dropouts |
Kantola et al,16 2002 | Yes | Yes | Yes | RCT | Yes | Yes | No |
Lawson et al,17 1970 | Yes | Yes | Yes | Crossover | Indeterminant | No | No |
Lehtovorta et al,18 2001 | Yes | Yes | Yes | RCT | Indeterminant | Yes | No dropouts |
More et al,19 1999 | Yes | Yes | Yes | Crossover | Indeterminant | No | Yes |
Paolisso et al,20 1998 | Yes | Yes | Yes | RCT | Indeterminant | No | No dropouts |
RCT = randomized controlled trial.