Table 4.
Variable | Subgroup | Number of Studies | Point Estimate (min) | 95% Confidence Interval | Heterogeneity (I2, %) | Deeks' χ2, P-Value |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Age (y) | Children (0 to 18) | 2 | −16.7 | −29.4, −4.0 | Negligible (0) | .0008 |
Adult (19 to 65) | 7 | −11.2 | −27.7, 5.4 | Substantial (84.0) | ||
Elderly (66 and older) | 5 | −10.3 | −20.1, −0.6 | Substantial (79.0) | ||
Dosage (mg) | <1 | 2 | −0.9 | −5.4, 3.6 | Negligible (0) | NA |
1 to 3 | 6 | −9.6 | −17.5, −1.7 | Substantial (54.6) | ||
4 to 5 | 7 | −13.8 | −28.9, 1.3 | Substantial (88.6) | ||
Study duration (wk) | <1 | 1 | −9.7 | −20.5, 1.1 | NA | .07 |
1–2 | 5 | −7.9 | −17.5, 1.6 | Negligible (0) | ||
3–4 | 8 | −13.6 | −22.0, −5.1 | Substantial (88.9) | ||
Primary diagnosis | Insomnia | 12 | −7.2 | −12.0, −2.4 | Substantial (60.5) | <.00001 |
Delayed sleep-phase syndrome | 2 | −38.8 | −50.3, −27.3 | Negligible (0) | ||
Study design | Parallel | 3 | −16.8 | −29.0, −4.7 | Negligible (0) | .008 |
Crossover | 11 | −10.8 | −17.9, −3.7 | Substantial (85.9) | ||
Jadad quality score | Moderate (Jadad score 2 to 3) | 4 | −5.4 | −11.8, 0.9 | Moderate (37.2) | .15 |
High (Jadad score 4 to 5) | 10 | −14.2 | −26.6, −1.7 | Substantial (85.9) | ||
Allocation concealment | Unclear | 11 | −10.1 | −17.4, −2.8 | Substantial (81.7) | .00006 |
Adequate | 3 | −16.4 | −24.3, −8.5 | Negligible (0) |
NA, not applicable