Table 1.
Differences between individual and population based approaches to obesity. Adapted from Swinburn et al (see Further Reading box)
| Individual based approach | Population based approach | |
|---|---|---|
|
Key measures |
Body weight, waist, body mass index |
Prevalence of overweight and obesity, mean body mass index, mean waist |
|
Key aetiology question |
Why is this person obese (or gaining weight)? |
Why does this population have a high (or rising) prevalence of obesity? |
|
Main aetiological mechanisms |
Genetic, metabolic, hormonal, behavioural |
Environmental, cultural, behavioural |
|
Key management question |
What are the best long term strategies for reducing the person's body fat? |
What are the best long term strategies for reducing the population's mean body fat/waist circumference? |
|
Main management actions |
Patient education, behavioural modification, drugs, surgery |
Public education, improving food, physical activity environments, policy, planning |
|
Volume of information on aetiology and management |
Vast |
Minimal |
|
Driving forces for research and action |
Immediate and powerful |
Distant and weak |
|
Potential for long term benefit to individuals |
Modest |
Modest |
|
Potential for long-term benefit to populations |
Modest |
Significant |
| Sustainability | Poor | High |