Table 5.
Author | Treatment | Follow up | Patients | Outcome | Postoperative |
Soravia52 | Duodenotomy with polypectomy (1) or ampullectomy (4) | 4–34 months &;(mean 18) | 5 FAP | Recurrence in 4 patients. 1 patient died of cancer | 1 transient duodenal fistula |
Morpurgo44 | Transduodenal ampullectomy (1) or polyp excision (1) | 6–24 months &;(mean 19) | 2 FAP | Recurrence in 1 patient | 1 severe pancreatitis |
Alarcon46 | Local resection | 8–33 months &;(mean 20.2) | 5 FAP | Recurrence in 4 patients. 1 had progressive metastatic adenocarcinoma | NS |
Heiskanen5 | Duodenotomy | 0.4–15.1 years &;(median 6.8) | 15 FAP | No significant difference in Spigelman stage preoperative and at latest endoscopy | No postoperative complications |
Penna56 | Duodenotomy with polypectomy | 5–36 months &;(mean 13.3) | 12 FAP | Recurrence in 12 patients | NS |
Penna57 | Duodenotomy with polypectomy | 36–72 months &;(mean 53) | 6 FAP | Recurrence in 6 patients | 1 cholecystectomy for cholecystitis, 2 duodenal fistulas |
de Vos tot Nederveen58 | Duodenotomy with ampullectomy | 4–13 months &;(mean 11) | 8 FAP | Recurrence in 6 patients | 1 minor morbidity* |
de Vos tot Nederveen58 | Duodenotomy with polypectomy | 5–103 months &;(mean 29) | 22 FAP | Recurrence in 17 patients. 1 death from metastatic disease | 1 minor morbidity* |
Ruo59 | Duodenotomy with ampullectomy | 35 months | 1 FAP | Gastric cancer arising from a polyp at 35 months | No postoperative complications |
Farnell60 | Transduodenal local excision | 10 years | 53 sporadic and FAP patients | Recurrence rate of 32% at 5 years and 43% at 10 years of follow up | 3 pancreatitis, 3 leaks, 2 delayed gastric emptying, 2 ileus, 1 fluid overload |
*That is, wound infection, atelectasis, or urinary tract infection.
NS, not stated; FAP, familial adenomatous polyposis.