Table 5.
Study | Design | Characteristics of the sample | Major findings |
Caffo et al. (1996) | • Retrospective "ad hoc" QOL questionnaire inquiry following RT | • 70 patients with localized PCA | • Psychological adjustment and relational well-being good • Level of available information about PCA and RT correlate with adjustment |
Joly et al. (1998) | • Retrospective, controlled study of health-related QOL (EORTC) | • 71 patients with localized disease treated with combined external beam RT and brachytherapy | • Treatment has no adverse effects • Patients and controls similar on a range of measures but sexual and urinary symptoms more common in patients |
Artebery et al. (1997) | • Retrospective questionnaire (EORTC Prostate) study following brachytherapy | • 51 patients with localized PCA | • Only a minority report psychological distress or disrupted social/family life • Return rate to work – 93% • 100% would recommend treatment to others |
Monga et al. (1997) | • Prospective • Aim was to determine cause of fatigue in PCA patients receiving RT through questionnaire (Beck Depression Inventory and 2 sleep scales) and measure of neuromuscular efficiency (NME) |
• 13 patients with localized PCA | • Significant but transient decline in NME, independent of psychological status; thus fatigue physically – based rather than influenced by depression |
Monga et al. (1999) | • Prospective evaluation, including fatigue, at 4 points – before, during and after RT • Same measures as in Monga et al. (1997) |
• 36 patients with localised PCA | • Fatigue scores significantly higher at end of treatment • Not associated with psychological status eg. depression or with sleep. • May be secondary to decline in neuromuscular efficiency and increased muscle fatigue |
Greenberg et al. (1993) | • Prospective study of fatigue and mood (Beck Depression Inventory) during treatment | • 15 patients with localised PCA | • Fatigue increases with treatment, but independent of depression • Fatigue associated with increased interleukin – 1 which could be a marker for fatigue associated with RT |