Robust and nonrobust perfect adaptation. The dependence of steady-state
system activity on total receptor concentration was calculated by using
equilibrium analysis for three concentrations of chemoattractant:
(i) L = 0 (solid),
(ii) L = 1 μM (dashed), and
(iii) L = 1 mM (dashed–dot). The
filled circle indicates the value of total receptor used in the model.
(a) Spiro model. The system activity is measured in
terms of the concentration of CheY-P. The intersection of the three
lines, which coincides with the filled circle, represents the value of
total receptor at which perfect adaptation exists. (b)
Barkai–Leibler model. The system activity is measured in terms of the
concentration of active receptor complexes. The three lines completely
overlap. These plots were performed by using the program
xppaut (34, 35).