Skip to main content
. 2007 May 11;2:15. doi: 10.1186/1748-5908-2-15

Table 3.

Methodological quality of included studies

CBA Methodological Quality Assessment Results and Rating
First Author Unit of Allocation Unit of Analysis Power Calculation Baseline Measure Characteristics of Control Blinded Outcome Assessment Protection Against Contamination Reliable Outcomes Measure Provider Follow Patient Follow Up Rating

Tsa i [27] Provider Provide r NC X NC X n/a Low

RCT Methodological Quality Assessment Results and Rating

First Author Unit of Allocation Unit of Analysis Power Calculation Baseline Measure Allocation Concealment Blinded Outcome Assessment Protection Against Contamination Reliable Outcomes Measure Provider Follow Up Patient Follow Up Rating

Dufault [24] Ward Provider * NC X NC X X NC n/a Low
Hong [25] Ward Provider * NC X X & NC NC n/a Low
Tranme r [26] Ward Provider * NC X NC X X NC n/a Low

√:Done

X: Not Done

NC: Not Clear

* Unit of analysis error

4/8 or less – low quality

5/8–6/8 – medium quality

7/8 or higher – high quality