Table 2.

Scholarship of Integration and Scholarship of Application Portfolio

Scholarship of Integration and Scholarship of Application Portfolio
The scholarship of integration gives meaning to specific discoveries by making connections within and between disciplines, locating knowledge in a broader context, making connections and synthesizing knowledge. The scholarship of application is focused on engagement with the broader community and the use that might be made of knowledge to address societal problems1,2,3,7
The Portfolio is designed to explain the objectives of the scholarship of integration and application activities, the thinking that underpinned it, and to demonstrate impact1,3,6. Developing the Portfolio contributes to scholarship through self-reflection, self-evaluation, and self-development. The Portfolio is a yearly record and a cumulative record of process and outcomes. Yearly records contribute to a cumulative record of historical data that will be useful when compiling award, grants, tenure and promotion applications4. Scholars include rationale for and description of each activity, and provide evidence of impact. The Portfolio reports knowledge transfer and exchange activities and products produced in collaboration with communities (engagement)23. It can be five to eight page document (plus appendices) organized into four sections:
1. Philosophy and clear goals
2. Contributions to the Scholarship of Integration and Application.
3. Reflections and Assessment.
4. Supporting Documentation4.
1. Philosophy and clear goals
1.1 Statement of your philosophy about the scholarship of integration and application, your goals and the theory, evidence and/or rationale guiding your work (Appendix A)
2. Contributions to the Scholarship of Integration and Application
2.1 Scholarship Activities and Funding awards: Objectives of projects and activities, describe underpinning thinking and theories, and how these activities contribute to mission of the academic institution and your discipline (Appendix B)
2.2 Activities to Improve Scholarship: Development and training to improve effectiveness (Appendix C)
2.3 Committee Service regarding Scholarship and Scholarship Issues: Faculty, academic institution and community activities to strengthen scholarship (Appendix D)
2.4 Knowledge Exchange Activities: Peer reviewed papers. Dissemination documents for wider audiences. Applied products to facilitate immediate transfer of knowledge into application. Plain language reports. Community dissemination products2,23 (Appendix E)
3. Reflection and Evaluation of Impact
3.1 Reflections on Scholarship impact: Summary statements that reflect your assessment of the effectiveness, impact, and results of your scholarship (Appendix F)
3.2 Integration scholarship: non-academic publications that are written for non-specialist audiences that show a critical, analytical and literary ability to interpret and translate complex scholarship into accessible communication. Questions for evaluators of this scholarship include: What do the findings mean? Is it possible to interpret what's been discovered in ways that provide a larger, more comprehensive understanding? Does the work show a careful understanding of the discipline? Have the key issues been well defined and creative insights well presented? Has the essential message been clarified? In what ways has the public discourse been advanced?2
3.3 Application scholarship – questions for evaluators include: Is the activity directly related to the academic expertise of the professor? Have project goals been defined, procedures well planned and actions carefully recorded? In what ways has the work not only benefited the recipients of such activity, but also added to the professor's own understanding of their academic field? How can knowledge be responsibly applied to consequential problems? How can it be helpful to individuals as well as institutions? Can social problems themselves define and agenda for scholarly investigation?2
3.4 Future Plans – Outline short-term goals (within one year) and long-term goals (two to five years) to further develop your scholarship program.
4. Supporting Documentation: eligible activities and products included as appendices:
Appendix A
• documents to illustrate your philosophy and goals.
Appendix B
• Funding awards, objectives of projects and activities.
• Examples of activities such as teaching interprofessional courses with colleagues from other disciplines, interprofessional curriculum development; seminars, advising students from other disciplines, supervision of an integrated or applied scholarship practicum; scholarship that contributed to the achievement of awards or employment for students. Cross-reference if such evidence is reported in your Scholarship of Teaching Portfolio.
Appendix C
• Description of efforts to improve knowledge, skills and methods on scholarship, e.g., seminars, lectures, workshops, and conferences attended. Reflection on your learning.
Appendix D
Include details such as names of committees, dates, and the nature of your contribution.
• Activities concerned with scholarship undertaken as a member of a faculty, department, or cross disciplinary committee, sub-committee, ad hoc committee, or task force, accreditation committees, program review committees, interdisciplinary curriculum development.
• Faculty resources developed, workshops, conferences organised. Use of your scholarship materials in other faculties, colleges, or universities.
• Participate in orientation sessions for new faculty, seminars, or invited presentations within and outside of the University about your knowledge transfer and exchange activities.
• Invited to consult by scholars in other faculties to improve applied scholarship effectiveness.
Appendix E
• Innovative dissemination strategies.
• Peer reviewed documents. Details of books (chapters in books, edited books); articles (refereed, solicited, or non-refereed); papers in conference proceedings (refereed or non-refereed); bibliographies; unpublished professional and technical reports.
• Applied products – innovative programs, policy development, training materials, resource manuals and technical products21
• Community dissemination products – newsletters; posters; workshop presentations; community forums, websites, media21
Appendix F
• Peer reviews from members in the community that your work was meant to benefit.
• Results of evaluations or questionnaires designed by you to obtain feedback about the effectiveness and impact of your activities.
• Solicited and unsolicited letters to attest evidence of your impact and effectiveness.