Table 2.
Study | Intervention type | Description of intervention | Home environmental effects | Health effects |
---|---|---|---|---|
Brunekreef et al. 2002 | Mechanical | Mite-impermeable bedding covers | Lower house dust mite count | No important clinical benefits in children < 2 years of age |
Halken 2004 | Mechanical | Mite-impermeable bedding covers | Lower house dust mite count | Reduced need for inhaled steroids in asthmatic children |
Popplewell et al. 2000 | Mechanical | HEPA and standard vacuum cleaners | Reduced house dust mite, cat and dog allergens with HEPA | Improved peak respiratory flow rate, bronchodilator usage |
Warner et al. 2002 | Mechanical | HEPA vacuum cleaners and whole-house mechanical ventilation system | Reduced dampness and house dust mite count | Improved histamine levels with whole-house ventilation; no significant added benefit from HEPA |
van der Heide 1999 | Mechanical | Bedroom and living room air cleaners | Reduced airborne cat and dog allergen | Improved peak expiratory flow rate; reduced airway hyper responsiveness |
Somerville et al. 2000 | Mechanical | Central heating systems | Reduced dampness; improved energy efficiency | Improved asthma outcome measures; fewer sick school days |
Wakefield et al. 2002 | Education | Parents refraining from smoking in the home | No significant difference in parental behavior | No significant improvement in children’s health |
McIntosh et al. 1994 | Education | Parents refraining from smoking in the home | No significant difference in parental behavior | No significant improvement in children’s health |
Fitzpatrick et al. 1992 | Education | Asthma camp for asthmatic children and their parents | Improved use of medication and breathing exercises | Reduced school absences, emergency department visits, and hospitalizations |
Krieger et al. 2005 | Combination | Community health workers deployed to Seattle, WA, homes: high-intensity, low-intensity interventions | Reduction in numerous home allergens | Reduced children’s asthma symptom days and use of urgent health services |
NCICAS
Kattan et al. 2005 Morgan et al. 2004 Sullivan et al. 2002 |
Combination | Seven cities: comprehensive home environmental interventions and education targeted to children’s allergies | Reduction in numerous home allergens | Reduction in asthma symptom days in children, use of albuterol inhalers, and unscheduled clinic visits |
Carter et al. 2001 Hayden et al. 1997 |
Combination | Interventions in homes of hospitalized asthmatic children with home visits: active, placebo, and control | Reduction in house dust mite | Reduced children’s acute asthma hospital visits; no difference in active vs. placebo groups |