Table 1.
OHTS | EGPS | |
---|---|---|
Design | Unmasked randomized clinical trial | Double-masked randomized, placebo controlled clinical trial |
Hypothesis | To evaluate the safety and efficacy of topical ocular hypotensive medication in preventing or delaying the onset of POAG in individuals with ocular hypertension | To evaluate the safety and efficacy of dorzolamide in preventing or delaying POAG in individuals with ocular hypertension |
Treatment Group | N=818 participants, treatment with any commercially available drug to achieve 20% IOP reduction from baseline and ≤ 24 mmHg | N=538 participants, treatment with dorzolamide |
Control Group | Observation N=819 | Placebo eye drops N=543 |
Median Follow-up | Every 6 months for 6.6 years | Every 6 months for 4.8 years |
Eligibility | ||
Age (Years) | 40–80 inclusive | > 30 |
IOP | ≥ 24 and ≤ 32 in one eye
≥ 21 and ≤ 32 fellow eye Mean of 4–6 IOPs in 2 Qualifying Visits Both eyes had to satisfy eye-specific eligibility criteria |
≥ 22 and ≤ 29 in at least 1 eye
Mean of 2–3 IOPs in 1 Eligibility Visit Both eyes had to satisfy eye-specific eligibility criteria except for IOP Some participants could have one eye entered into the study |
Normal Optic Disc | Clinical exam and masked reading of stereophotographs, difference in cup/disc ratio between eyes not greater than 0.2 | Similar |
Visual Fields | Normal and reliable Humphrey 30-2 visual fields | Normal and reliable Humphrey 30-2 visual fields or Octopus 32-2 visual fields |
Exclusions | Pigment dispersion or exfoliation syndrome | Not excluded |
Best corrected visual acuity worse than20/40 in either eye | Same | |
Previous intraocular surgery except uncomplicated extracapsular cataract extraction with posterior chamber IOL | Same | |
A life threatening or debilitating disease | Same | |
Secondary causes of elevated IOP | Same except for pigment dispersion or exfoliation syndrome | |
Angle closure glaucoma or anatomically narrow angles | Same | |
Systemic or ocular conditions capable of causing visual field loss or optic disc abnormalities | Same | |
Background diabetic retinopathy | Same | |
Pregnant or nursing women | Same | |
Endpoint Ascertainment | Independent, masked readers | Same |
Visual Fields | 3 consecutive abnormal and reliable tests with defect in the same location and index | Same |
Optic Discs | 2 consecutive sets of photographs judged to have a clinically significant change | 1 set of photographs judged to have changed by at least 2 of 3 masked readers |
Attribution to POAG | Masked endpoint committee | Same |
EGPS European Glaucoma Prevention Study
IOL Intraocular lens
IOP Intraocular pressure
OHTS Ocular Hypertension Treatment Study
POAG Primary open angle glaucoma