Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2008 Mar 1.
Published in final edited form as: Bone. 2006 Dec 15;40(3):767–774. doi: 10.1016/j.bone.2006.10.025

Table 1.

Results from the literature for DXA and QCT measures vs. ex vivo vertebral strength.

Author No. samples Age Specimen Type Scan Type Independent variable Dependent Variable R2
Edmondston[15] 250 29 – 88 Isolated
vertebrae
DXA
QCT
BMD
tBMD
Fu, σu 0.46, 0.28
0.67, 0.53
Brinckmann[4] 98 19 - 79 Spinal
sections
QCT iBMD
IBMD x Amin
Fu 0.38
0.64
Moro[13] 11 48 - 87 Spinal
sections
DXA BMD Fu 0.69
Eriksson[5] 73 59 - 94 Isolated
vertebrae
QCT iBMD
iBMD x Amin
Fu 0.23
0.55
Singer[20] 306 29 - 89 Isolated
vertebrae
QCT tBMD
iBMD
tBMD x Amin
Fu 0.08
0.74
0.69
McBroom[19] 40 63 - 99 Isolated
vertebrae
QCT TBMD Fu 0.46
Ebbesen[16] 101 18 - 96 Isolated
vertebrae
DXA BMD
tBMD
Fu, σu 0.83, 0.71
0.61, 0.76
Cheng[14] 62 68 + 16 Isolated
vertebrae
DXA
QCT
QCT
BMD
tBMD
tBMD x Amin
Fu, σu 0.64, 0.40
0.40, 0.50
0.61, 0.40
Mosekilde[12] 30 43 - 95 Isolated
vertebrae
QCT TBMD Fu, σu 0.52, 0.30
Lochmuller[22] 126 82 + 9 Spinal
sections
DXA
QCT
BMD
tBMD
Fu 0.62
0.48
Eckstein[34] 39 79 + 11 Spinal
sections
QCT TBMD Fu 0.66

QCT = quantitative computed tomography

DXA = dual x-ray absorptiometry

Fu = ex vivo ultimate axial compressive force

σu = ex vivo ultimate axial compressive strength

Spinal sections = two or more vertebrae with discs

Amin = minimum transverse plane cross sectional area

BMD = DXA-measured bone mineral density using anterior-posterior projection

tBMD = trabecular bone mineral density,

iBMD = integral bone mineral density, including vertebral cortex and endplates