Skip to main content
. 2007 Sep 9;13(12):1173–1213. doi: 10.1007/s00894-007-0233-4

Table 18.

Comparison of B3LYP and PM6 hydrogen bond energies (kcal mol−1)

Hydrogen-bonded system Ref PM6 PM5 PM3 AM1
Ammonia - ammonia −2.94 −2.34 −0.77 −0.67 −1.41
Water - methanol −4.90 −5.12 −2.59 −0.20 −4.52
Water - acetone −5.51 −5.25 −2.43 −2.22 −4.09
Water, dimer, linear (O–H–O = 180°) −5.00 −3.69 −1.57 −3.49 −3.16
Water, dimer −5.00 −4.88 −2.43 −1.95 −5.01
Benzene dimer, T-shaped −2.34 −0.83 −0.22 −0.56 −0.07
Water - acetate anion −19.22 −18.72 −12.28 −15.77 −15.91
Water - formaldehyde −5.17 −4.22 −2.17 −2.73 −3.40
Water - ammonia −6.36 −4.32 −2.75 −1.53 −2.90
Water - formamide −8.88 −7.60 −4.14 −4.33 −7.54
Formic acid, dimer −13.90 −10.03 −4.75 −8.65 −6.44
Water - methylammonium cation −18.76 −14.90 −8.94 −10.48 −14.36
Formamide - formamide −13.55 −10.83 −4.46 −6.08 −8.14
Acetic acid, dimer −14.89 −10.33 −4.50 −8.70 −6.44