Skip to main content
. 2007 Sep 9;13(12):1173–1213. doi: 10.1007/s00894-007-0233-4

Table 5.

Average unsigned errors in calculated heats of formation (kcal mol−1)

Element PM6 No. PM5 No. PM3 No. AM1 No.
Hydrogen 7.29 3039 13.89 2340 17.09 2340 21.12 2270
Helium 0.00 1 0.00 1 0.00 1 0.00 1
Lithium 7.98 83 15.31 83 18.02 83 18.84 82
Beryllium 5.92 34 29.06 34 29.58 34 18.51 34
Boron 6.44 122 10.81 120 11.84 120
Carbon 7.31 2828 13.03 2155 15.06 2155 19.42 2123
Nitrogen 8.22 1067 16.45 761 20.96 761 24.23 744
Oxygen 8.42 1758 16.59 1243 20.13 1244 27.68 1229
Fluorine 8.49 497 22.31 350 21.25 350 37.40 334
Neon 0.00 1 0.00 1 0.00 1 0.00 1
Sodium 5.72 40 8.57 39 9.47 39 10.77 38
Magnesium 9.84 66 12.07 66 17.94 66 18.71 66
Aluminum 7.61 75 17.49 75 19.15 75 18.99 75
Silicon 6.51 98 9.28 96 12.80 96 17.00 95
Phosphorus 8.20 110 16.01 98 17.36 98 20.06 95
Sulfur 8.81 427 15.40 330 18.44 330 26.38 323
Chlorine 8.28 670 16.69 390 18.71 390 23.06 383
Argon 0.00 1 0.00 1 0.00 1 0.00 1
Potassium 6.53 43 12.33 42 9.36 42 28.38 41
Calcium 11.87 43 28.68 43 43.44 43 63.20 43
Scandium 10.33 52
Titanium 10.20 85
Vanadium 14.29 59
Chromium 14.09 60
Manganese 12.77 44
Iron 18.31 76
Cobalt 15.51 42
Nickel 15.10 51
Copper 13.00 47
Zinc 5.56 54 17.84 54 32.93 54 37.06 54
Gallium 7.51 47 29.12 47 37.58 47 46.87 47
Germanium 9.83 67 12.20 67 15.86 67 19.12 67
Arsenic 6.94 49 15.22 49 16.68 49 17.34 49
Selenium 4.40 25 39.58 25 39.71 25 32.00 25
Bromine 7.37 330 17.20 199 25.04 199 28.22 199
Krypton 0.00 1 0.00 1 0.00 1 0.00 1
Rubidium 10.91 24 16.57 24 21.47 24 29.33 23
Strontium 7.72 38 52.46 38 103.16 38 57.21 38
Yttrium 13.28 51
Zirconium 11.18 46
Niobium 8.57 51
Molybdenum 13.41 70 35.77 69
Technetium 15.14 50
Ruthenium 13.87 56
Rhodium 20.92 32
Palladium 11.65 47
Silver 4.67 14
Cadmium 3.49 38 34.66 38 61.92 38
Indium 7.33 54 31.53 54 29.83 54 32.16 54
Tin 7.14 77 16.83 77 17.10 77 20.21 77
Antimony 5.41 58 30.98 58 34.61 58 35.00 58
Tellurium 8.20 45 35.66 45 46.80 45 22.91 45
Iodine 7.23 279 23.77 176 25.90 176 36.55 175
Xenon 0.00 1 0.00 1 0.00 1 0.00 1
Cesium 6.89 40 37.01 40 35.22 40 55.33 39
Barium 12.12 37 98.20 37 154.65 37 161.09 37
Lanthanum 10.37 37
Lutetium 7.68 24
Hafnium 8.52 37
Tantalum 14.37 36
Tungsten 7.38 28
Rhenium 10.40 57
Osmium 6.46 19
Iridium 10.21 25
Platinum 11.61 77
Gold 12.82 32
Mercury 5.94 51 16.39 51 17.67 51 19.75 51
Thallium 10.42 44 32.63 44 73.96 45 73.18 45
Lead 7.92 44 18.08 44 14.18 44 16.71 44
Bismuth 7.74 53 99.88 53 28.95 53 119.23 53