Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2008 Jan 15.
Published in final edited form as: Phys Rev E Stat Nonlin Soft Matter Phys. 2006 Sep 26;74(3 Pt 1):31916. doi: 10.1103/PhysRevE.74.031916

TABLE I.

MSE Values and standard deviations (see Appendix C for computation) for studied methods and models. “*” denotes methods that are nearly insensitive to changes in the coupling degree and for which this criterion is not applicable.

M1 M2 M3 M4a (S/N=inf) M4a (S/N=2) M4b (S/N=inf) M4b (S/N=2) M5(SPK) M5(BKG)
R2 0.12 ±0.004 76.42 ±4.55 109.55±2.55 0.28 ±0.01 0.22 ±0.01 0.26 ±0.03 0.22 ±0.02 63.17 ±3.08 1.54 ±0.09
CF 104.48 ±0.33 108.22 ±0.41 91.14 ±5.61 107.14 ±0.32 107.83 ±0.41 102.53 ±0.08 104.17 ±0.37 * *
h2 1.10 ±0.01 117.45 ±3.78 151.14±2.38 3.43 ±0.04 1.33 ±0.01 2.73 ±0.02 1.12 ±0.02 103.79±3.25 5.99 ±0.13
HE 4.98 ±0.02 23.11 ±0.61 63.82 ±0.38 8.09 ±0.03 6.87 ±0.03 6.00 ±0.01 5.69 ±0.02 28.75 ±0.49 *
HR 3.00 ±0.11 175.56±5.52 473.07±2.23 6.26 ±0.21 4.99 ±0.13 2.74 ±0.06 3.04 ±0.10 249.31±5.28 18.99 ±0.61
WE 10.54 ±0.02 20.48 ±0.32 76.47 ±0.55 13.01 ±0.04 13.27 ±0.05 12.98 ±0.01 12.76 ±0.03 * *
WR 8.78 ±0.1 113.65±2.97 161.50 ±1.36 68.97 ±0.32 65.79 ±0.35 62.26 ±0.05 64.22 ±0.28 53.39 ±0.88 *
S 75.51 ±0.1 28.45 ±0.82 26.59 ±0.48 0.03 ±0.0001 27.47 ±0.06 0.03 ±0.0002 27.41 ±0.07 107.53 ±2.51 120.04 ±0.104
H 0.44 ±0.28 2228.14 ±34.87 441.99 ±14.04 1.86 ±0.18 0.50 ±0.09 1.04±0.22 0.39 ±0.21 651.21±45.65 4.21 ±11.60
N 0.41 ±0.35 378.44 ±3.50 116.76±5.77 0.63±0.34 0.30±0.27 0.55 ±0.32 0.33 ±0.26 201.46 ±15.30 4.90 ±1.87
SL 4.28 ±0.33 115.25±2.58 8.50 ±2.19 4.18 ±0.33 4.47 ±0.25 3.83 ±0.23 3.74 ±0.30 41.32 ±5.58 6.16±0.88