Skip to main content
. 2007 May;92(5):416–422. doi: 10.1136/adc.2006.113589

Table 1 Overview of all diagnostic accuracy studies identified.

Study details Selection procedure No. weighed (% of approached) No. males (%) and ethnicity Weighed age(s)
Bedogni (2003)11 A convenience sample of children enrolled in primary and 986 (not 486 (49%) 8–12 years
Italy secondary schools in Modena and Parma. Year of data reported)
collection not reported.
Ebbeling (1999)12 Information on children was obtained from data tapes from 1171 (not 585 (50%) 6–9 years
USA the NHANESII study which was carried out in 1976–1980. reported)
Ellis (1999)13 Selection procedure was not explicitly stated; children were 979 (not 406 (41%) 3–18 years
USA living in Houston, Texas. Data were collected in 1994–1996. reported) African American (Black) 283
European American (White) 438
Hispanic American (Hispanic) 258
Himes (1989)14 Families in Quebec City volunteered to participate in response 316 (not 159 (50%) 8–18 years
USA to media notices. Year of data collection not reported. reported)
Lazarus (1996)15 Volunteers recruited from among siblings of outpatients 230 (not 119 (52%) 4–20 years
Australia or children of staff and friends at The Children's reported)
Hospital, Sydney. Year of data collection not reported.
Marshall (1991)16 Children from Alberta who participated in the Canada 540 (90%) 266 (49%) 7–14 years
Canada fitness survey in 1981 were selected using a two‐stage
stratified sampling frame.
Mast (2002)17 Random sample (40%) of children in 29/32 schools in Kiel 2286 (not 1146 (50%) 5–7 years
Germany in 1996–1999. reported)
Reilly (1999)18 Unclear, though it was stated that they were representative 240 (not 124 (52%) 8 years
UK of Scottish children (based in Edinburgh). Year of data reported)
collection not reported.
Reilly (2000)19 4175 of approx 14 000 children in the Avon Longitudinal 3948 (95%) 2010 (51%) 7 years
UK Study of Pregnancy and Childhood (ALSPAC) in 1998. The
sample was representative of the birth cohort and UK,
although slightly over‐representative of wealthier families
and under‐representative of ethnic minorities.
Schaefer (1998)20 Representative sample (19%) of the population in the area of 2554 (not 1276 (50%) 6–19 years
Germany Heidelberg in 1989/1990. reported)
Wickramasinghe Not explicitly reported. The authors stated that subjects were 138 (not 71 (51%) 5–15 years
(2005)21 contacted via newsletters and community centres in Brisbane. reported) Australian Sri Lankan 42
Australia Year of data collection not reported. Australian White Caucasian 96