Table 5.
Procrustes anova table for object asymmetry analysis for the entire skull as well as the three cranial subregions. Object FA was calculated as recommended by Klingenberg et al. (2002) and was calculated using the program Sage3D
Group and region | d.f. | SS | MS | F | P value | FA10 |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Whole skull | ||||||
Wildtype 3H1 (+/+) | ||||||
Individual | 2840 | 0.496730 | 0.00017490 | |||
Reflection | 69 | 0.013946 | 0.00020212 | 4.50 | < 0.001 | |
Individual × reflection | 2760 | 0.124110 | 0.00004497 | 10.95 | < 0.001 | 0.002943 |
Measurement error | 11480 | 0.046756 | 0.00000407 | |||
Br 3H1 (Br/+) | ||||||
Individual | 3621 | 0.874430 | 0.00024149 | |||
Reflection | 69 | 0.074450 | 0.00107900 | 20.83 | < 0.001 | |
Individual × reflection | 3519 | 0.182430 | 0.00005184 | 8.82 | < 0.001 | 0.003122 |
Measurement error | 14560 | 0.085558 | 0.00000588 | |||
Basicranium | ||||||
Wildtype 3H1 (+/+) | ||||||
Individual | 320 | 1.470900 | 0.00459670 | |||
Reflection | 8 | 0.000858 | 0.00010721 | 0.08 | < 0.05 | |
Individual × reflection | 320 | 0.456900 | 0.00142780 | 4.75 | < 0.001 | 0.015468 |
Measurement error | 1312 | 0.394530 | 0.00030071 | |||
Br 3H1 (Br/+) | ||||||
Individual | 408 | 3.560200 | 0.00872600 | |||
Reflection | 8 | 0.018014 | 0.00251700 | 0.79 | > 0.05 | |
Individual × reflection | 408 | 1.298000 | 0.00318140 | 12.54 | < 0.001 | 0.024929 |
Measurement error | 1664 | 0.422250 | 0.00025375 | |||
Face | ||||||
Wildtype 3H1 (+/+) | ||||||
Individual | 560 | 0.940460 | 0.00167940 | |||
Reflection | 14 | 0.004518 | 0.00032271 | 0.98 | > 0.05 | |
Individual × reflection | 560 | 0.184290 | 0.00032910 | 12.66 | < 0.001 | 0.008021 |
Measurement error | 2296 | 0.059689 | 0.00002600 | |||
Br 3H1 (Br/+) | ||||||
Individual | 714 | 1.553800 | 0.00217620 | |||
Reflection | 14 | 0.006831 | 0.00048792 | 1.01 | > 0.05 | |
Individual × reflection | 714 | 0.344420 | 0.00048238 | 8.53 | < 0.001 | 0.009507 |
Measurement error | 2912 | 0.164760 | 0.00005658 | |||
Neurocranium | ||||||
Wildtype 3H1 (+/+) | ||||||
Individual | 440 | 0.616020 | 0.00140010 | |||
Reflection | 9 | 0.155900 | 0.01732300 | 43.08 | < 0.001 | |
Individual × reflection | 360 | 0.144730 | 0.00040204 | 15.05 | < 0.001 | 0.008926 |
Measurement error | 1640 | 0.043825 | 0.00002672 | |||
Br 3H1 (Br/+) | ||||||
Individual | 560 | 0.741630 | 0.00132200 | |||
Reflection | 9 | 0.203610 | 0.02262400 | 63.66 | < 0.001 | |
Individual × reflection | 459 | 0.163120 | 0.00035538 | 10.30 | < 0.001 | 0.008253 |
Measurement error | 2080 | 0.071735 | 0.00003449 |