Table 2. Significant Findings for Neural Response during the Reward Task, by Task Phase.
Effect | Region | F | p | ds | Direction of Effects |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Group X Probability | L Amygdala | 7.35 | .007 | .19 | D>C (high probability), |
-.34 | D<C (low probability) | ||||
L OFC Inf | 6.63 | .010 | .10 | D>C (high probability), | |
-.34 | D<C (low probability) | ||||
Group X Magnitude | L OFC Inf | 15.81 | <.0005∼ | .13 | D>C (high reward), |
-.41 | D<C (low reward) | ||||
R OFC Inf | 11.74 | .001 | -.66 | D<<C (low reward) | |
-.17 | D<C (high reward) | ||||
R OFC Sup | 11.35 | .001 | -.13 | D<C (low reward) | |
.32 | D>C (high reward) | ||||
M OFC Rectus | 20.54 | <.0005 | -.42 | D<C (low reward) | |
.13 | D>>C (high reward) | ||||
Group | ACC | 4.04 | .047 | -.37 | D<C |
L OFC Sup | 7.73 | .006 | .40 | D>C | |
L Caudate | 4.12 | .044∼∼ | -.32 | D<C | |
4.49+ | .001 | ||||
R Caudate | 6.82 | .000 | -.39 | D<C | |
3.27+ | .007 | ||||
R OFC Inf | 8.00 | .005∼∼ | -.40 | D<C | |
Probability x Magnitude | L Amygdala | 4.97 | .026 | High>Low Probability (high reward), | |
High<Low Probability (low reward), | |||||
L Caudate | 13.89 | <.0005 | High>Low Probability (high reward), | ||
High<Low Probability (low reward), | |||||
R Caudate | 7.94 | .005 | High<Low Probability (high reward), | ||
High = Low Probability (Low reward), | |||||
Probability | L Amygdala | 5.88 | .016 | Low>high | |
R OFC Mid | 18.13 | <.0005 | Low>high | ||
R OFC Sup | 7.62 | .006 | Low>high | ||
Magnitude | ACC | 40.9 | <.0005 | Low>high | |
L Amygdala | 11.711 | .001 | Low>high | ||
R Amygdala | 13.21 | <.0005 | Low>high | ||
L OFC Sup | 9.07 | .003 | Low>high | ||
R OFC Sup | 5.79 | .017 | Low>high | ||
R OFC Inf | 28.005 | <.0005 | Low>high | ||
26.26+ | .023 | Low>high especially at the middle scans | |||
R OFC Mid | 26.11 | <.0005 | Low>high | ||
M OFC Rectus | 14.25 | <.0005 | Low>high | ||
| |||||
Group X Outcome | ACC | 1.907 | .127 | -.25 | D<C (reward) |
-.45 | D<<C (loss) | ||||
L Amygdala | 4.126 | .006 | .32 | D>C (Large) | |
-.03 | D=C (Small) | ||||
R Amygdala | 3.80 | .01 | .06 | D>C (Large Reward) | |
.01 | D<=C (all other conditions) | ||||
L OFC Inf | 3.10 | .026∼ | .08 | D>C (Large reward) | |
-.13 | D<C (all other conditions) | ||||
Group | ACC | 19.185 | .000 | -.37 | D<C |
L Amygdala | 6.102 | .014 | .19 | D>C | |
L Caudate | 16.12 | <.0005∼ | -.36 | D<C | |
L OFC Mid | 25.18 | <.0005 | -.47 | D<C | |
R OFC Mid | 9.26 | .003∼∼ | -.27 | D<C | |
L OFC Sup | 6.25 | .013∼∼ | -.26 | D<C | |
Outcome | ACC | 6.048 | .000∼∼ | Small<Large | |
L Amygdala | 3.558 | .014 | Small<Large | ||
R Amygdala | 21.95 | <.0005 | Small<Large | ||
L Caudate | 1.754 | .155 | Small<Large (especially at scans 3-4) | ||
R Caudate | 3.92 | .009 | Win>Loss | ||
3.60+ | <.0005 | Win>Loss (especially at scans 3-4) | |||
L OFC Mid | 11.13 | <.0005∼∼ | Large Loss<Small Loss<Small | ||
Reward<Large Reward | |||||
R OFC Mid | 9.99 | <.0005∼∼ | Small<Large | ||
OFC Med Rectus | 12.22 | <.0005 | Large>Small, Reward>Loss | ||
R OFC Inf | 5.35 | .001∼∼ | Large Loss<Small Loss<Small | ||
Reward<Large Reward | |||||
R OFC Sup | 6.748 | <.0005 | Small<Large |
occurred in interaction with scan, so that time-course of effect varied above and beyond group or condition-related differences in area under the curve
qualified by interaction with first versus second half, p<.05
qualified by interaction with first versus second half, p<.01
Note: D=Depression group; A=Anxiety group; C=Control; ds=effect size, ; ACC=anterior cingulate cortex; OFC=orbitofrontal cortex; L=left; R=right; Inf=inferior; Sup=superior; M=medial. Italics ➔ p<.05, but not significant after controlling for type 1 error using conservative threshold of p<.01.
df: Decision Phase: Diagnosis (1,101.9-192.3), Probability (1,634.9-683.9), Reward (1, 294.8-453.6), Probability x Reward: (1, 542.4-652.1). Interactions with diagnosis did not change df for Reward and Probability effects.