Skip to main content
. 1998 Aug 18;95(17):9724–9731. doi: 10.1073/pnas.95.17.9724

Table 2.

Means and standard deviations (SD) of the Pangloss value (vP), Nash high value (vH), Nash low value (vL), gains from cooperation (gH and gL), and frequencies of advantages to cooperation, in simulated two-person games with random payoffs independently distributed according to the uniform, exponential, normal, and lognormal distributions

m νP
vH
vL
gH gL Frequency νP > vH SD of frequency Frequency νP > vL SD of frequency
Mean SD Mean SD Mean SD
Uniform random elements
2 1.4157 0.0284 1.3122 0.0342 1.2398 0.0359 1.3318 1.7339 0.36 0.0480 0.50 0.0500
3 1.5907 0.0199 1.4449 0.0298 1.2970 0.0286 1.3277 1.9884 0.55 0.0497 0.77 0.0421
4 1.7056 0.0148 1.5828 0.0262 1.3279 0.0269 1.2107 2.1520 0.47 0.0499 0.84 0.0367
5 1.7384 0.0130 1.5813 0.0245 1.2922 0.0258 1.2703 2.5273 0.63 0.0483 0.92 0.0271
6 1.8118 0.0098 1.6977 0.0192 1.3148 0.0247 1.1636 2.5791 0.55 0.0497 0.90 0.0300
7 1.8202 0.0094 1.6810 0.0205 1.2892 0.0219 1.2046 2.8366 0.64 0.0480 0.98 0.0140
8 1.8319 0.0088 1.7138 0.0174 1.2739 0.0199 1.1654 3.0367 0.59 0.0492 0.98 0.0140
10 1.8823 0.0066 1.7725 0.0176 1.2199 0.0172 1.1421 4.0125 0.60 0.0490 0.98 0.0140
Exponential random elements
2 3.4815 0.1411 2.8728 0.1618 2.5108 0.1507 1.6974 2.9002 0.48 0.05 0.65 0.0477
3 4.7606 0.1677 3.8955 0.1855 3.0581 0.1689 1.4564 2.6091 0.50 0.05 0.72 0.0449
4 4.9592 0.1407 3.7552 0.1705 3.0805 0.1635 1.6859 2.7387 0.61 0.0488 0.79 0.0407
5 5.9810 0.1700 4.4791 0.1953 3.1167 0.1402 1.6058 3.5650 0.63 0.0483 0.87 0.0336
6 5.8790 0.1225 4.3161 0.1577 3.0923 0.1501 1.6748 3.5514 0.73 0.0444 0.94 0.0237
7 6.4515 0.1321 4.7634 0.1978 2.9706 0.1177 1.6109 4.5863 0.67 0.0470 0.95 0.0218
8 6.9736 0.1598 5.2178 0.1906 2.9158 0.1196 1.5457 5.4306 0.79 0.0407 0.98 0.0140
10 7.2419 0.1339 5.5513 0.1757 2.7568 0.0965 1.4761 6.9264 0.71 0.0454 0.98 0.0140
Normal random elements
2 1.5460 0.0990 1.0982 0.1328 0.9580 0.1306 1.4078 1.6138 0.44 0.0496 0.53 0.0499
3 2.1637 0.0875 1.6321 0.1144 0.9772 0.1128 1.3257 2.2142 0.46 0.0498 0.72 0.0449
4 2.4020 0.0785 1.8329 0.1044 1.1692 0.1096 1.3105 2.0543 0.58 0.0494 0.82 0.0384
5 2.7643 0.0747 2.2084 0.1143 1.0749 0.1055 1.2517 2.5717 0.51 0.0500 0.85 0.0357
6 3.0859 0.0705 2.2795 0.1112 0.9262 0.0784 1.3538 3.3319 0.64 0.0480 0.95 0.0218
7 3.2937 0.0635 2.6162 0.1093 0.8942 0.0789 1.2589 3.6832 0.59 0.0492 0.98 0.0140
8 3.5375 0.0562 2.8731 0.1012 0.9247 0.0713 1.2312 3.8256 0.65 0.0477 1 0
10 3.6397 0.0667 2.8989 0.1110 0.6496 0.0574 1.2556 5.6031 0.66 0.0474 0.99 0.0099
Lognormal random elements
2 5.7816 0.2759 4.7429 0.2839 4.2310 0.2557 1.7186 2.6609 0.38 0.0485 0.51 0.0500
3 7.9461 0.3982 5.9691 0.4053 4.9034 0.3698 1.7400 2.8946 0.58 0.0494 0.74 0.0439
4 12.1749 0.6061 7.3961 0.5582 4.9426 0.3738 2.1660 5.3960 0.71 0.0454 0.90 0.0300
5 13.6882 0.6132 7.7887 0.5528 4.5540 0.2558 2.3135 8.2694 0.73 0.0444 0.95 0.0218
6 15.2887 0.8331 9.1590 0.6870 5.0921 0.3389 2.0458 6.6815 0.73 0.0444 0.94 0.0237
7 16.1433 0.8001 8.6974 0.6402 5.0961 0.3438 2.3789 7.1421 0.80 0.0400 0.96 0.0196
8 16.6446 0.8053 10.1846 0.6489 4.9593 0.2922 1.9380 8.0315 0.74 0.0439 0.96 0.0196
10 19.4218 0.8089 11.2659 0.7444 5.6061 0.6422 2.0235 6.9842 0.79 0.0407 0.94 0.0237