Skip to main content
. 2007 Nov 1;57(544):904–911. doi: 10.3399/096016407782317892

Table 1.

Studies of paediatric consultations in primary care.

Author, setting and country Type of study Findings: child's contribution to the consultation
Pantell et al19 Primary care university medical centre, US Quantitative observational study of 115 videotaped paediatric consultations The child's contribution, which was largely social, was 14.2% of the consultation.

Meeuwesen et al20 General practice, The Netherlands Quantitative study of 95 videotapes of paediatric triadic consultations taken from an archived collection dating from 1975–1989 Child's contribution was small, increasing slightly over the years. Child-doctor interaction was between 3–6% of turns.

Tates and Meeuwesen21 General practice, The Netherlands Quantitative observational study of 106 video recordings of paediatric consultations from an archived collection Turn allocation was examined. Children had 9.4% of turns. GPs tended to take child's age into account but parents did not.

Eminson et al22 General practice, UK. Quantitative study using a triadic scale developed for the study to rate 66 GP consultations for involving the child in the consultation, before and after a teaching package was administered on triadic consultation skills The GPs scored high at involving the child in the history and early stages of the consultation prior to the teaching. But after the teaching package, were better at involving the child in the later parts of the consultation than before the training.

Tates et ala23 General practice, The Netherlands Qualitative study analysing 106 videotapes of paediatric consultations, from an achieved source. The participants' roles and identities were analysed A child being invited to begin the consultation increased their involvement in problem formulation. All three participants jointly establish a situation where the consultations end up with the parent speaking for the child, this being a social co-construction where the norm is parents speaking for children.

Tates et alb24 General practice, The Netherlands Quantitative study of 106 video recordings of paediatric consultations from an achieved source. Coded for instrumental versus affective behaviour of the participants Child's contribution was 9.6% of the consultation. GPs accommodated for the child's age. Parents did not accommodate for age, 80% of advice given on treatment by the GP is directed towards the parent not the child.

Tates cet al25 General Practice, The Netherlands Quantitative study of 105 videos of paediatric consultations taken from an archive coded for supportiveness of adults towards child involvement in the consultation and displays of child involvement Children have limited involvement, especially at the end of the consultation. GPs and parents mostly assumed a non-supportive role in interaction with the child, 90% of consultations end with child non-participation. When the parents are not supportive towards the child's involvement the consultations are more likely to be doctor–adult dyads.

Cahill and Papageorgiou General practice, UK18 A qualitative study of 31 paediatric primary care consultations The child's contribution was 5.42%. Adult carers interrupted doctor–child talk when the adults had not had their concerns expressed early in the consultation.