Table 1.
A few representative studies on overlapping genes, organized alphabetically with summary of principle conclusions and data type
Authors | Year | Genomes | IE | VE | SM | Genes & Homology | Evolutionary Process |
Lillo & Krakauer | 2007 | 58 Prokaryote | RC & TC | MA & MB | NS | Study of E. coli genome | Neutrality & Selection |
Boi et al [2] | 2004 | ? Eukaryote | GR | NS | NS | NS | Selection on regulation |
Das & Yanofsky [3] | 1989 | 1 Prokaryote | TC | NS | NS | Study of 2 genes | Selection on expression |
Fukuda et al. [6] | 1999 | 2 Prokaryote | NS | NS | NE | Study of 480 & 677 genes | Neutral mutation to stop codon |
Fukuda et al [7] | 2003 | 3 Prokaryote | NS | NS | NS | NS | Neutral mutation to stop and start |
Johnson & Chisholm [13] | 2004 | 198 Prokaryote | TC | NS | NS | Study of 2 genomes | Selection on expression |
Krakauer [15] | 2000 | NS | RC & TC | MA | NS | NS | Selection on replication and expression |
Krakauer [16] | 2002 | NS | RC & TC | MA & MB | NS | NS | Selection on replication and expression |
Makalowska et al. [22] | 2005 | 7 Eukaryote | GR | NS | NS | NS | Neutrality |
Merino et al. [25] | 1994 | 28 Prok & 8 Euk | GR | NS | NS | Study of E. coli genome | Selection on regulation |
Miyata & Yasunaga [24] | 1978 | 1 Prokaryote | NS | MA | NS | Study of -x174 | Selection on replication |
Normark et al. [26] | 1983 | ? Prokaryote | TC | NS | NS | NS | Selection on expression |
Oppenheim & Yanofsky [28] | 1980 | 1 Prokaryote | TC | NS | NS | E. coli Trp operon | Selection on expression |
Pavesi et al. [29] | 1997 | ? Viral | NS | MB | IC | NS | Selection on coding |
Rogozin et al. [30] | 2002 | ? Prokaryotes | NS | MB | NS | NS | Selection on coding |
Sakharkar et al [31] | 2005 | 9 Prokaryotes | RC | NS | NS | Study of 2 genomes | Selection on replication |
Sander & Schulz [32] | 1979 | 2 Prokaryote | NS | MB | NS | Study of SV40 & -x174 genes | Selection on coding |
Welch et al. [39] | 2000 | 1 Prokaryote | TC | NS | NS | Study of V anguillarum | Selection for iron biosynthesis |
Key: IE – Immediate Effect, VE – variational effect, SM – Statistical Model NS – Not in Study, TC – translational coupling, RC – replicative compression, GR antisense gene regulation MB – mutational buffering, MA – mutational amplification, NE – Neutral expectation under statistical model, IC – Shannon information content of overlap. The ? symbols records an unknown number lineages. The column labeled "Genes and detailed homology" captures the pattern of many studies to couple the statistics of large databases with the detailed analysis of a small number of overlapping genes from well studied genomes. The difference between selection on expression versus selection on regulation seeks to discriminate between co-expression (as in a codon) and active inhibition or activation (such as through anti-sense), The difference between selection on replication and selection on coding reflects a difference only in emphasis as both imply a greater number of genes in a shorter sequence.