Table 1.
TM-1 | TM-2 | TM-3,4 | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
TREMOR | • 41 significant TFs detected | • 98 TM-2s detected. | • 63 TM-3s detected. | |
• 15 TFs have P-values lower than the lowest P-value in the randomly permuted set. | • 35 include E2F and 36 include NF-Y. | • All include NF-Y and 15 include E2F. | ||
• NF-Y is at rank 1, E2F at rank 2 and CREB at rank 12 | • Rank-1 TM-2—(NF-Y c- Myc:Max). These TFs form a complex in cell cycle regulation. | • 158 TM-4s detected. | ||
• Of the remaining 12, 7 have evidence of potential cell cycle involvement: HOXA7 (34) (the reference shows evidence of involvement of a close relative, Hoxa-10), Elk-1 (35), ETF (36) (ETF regulates p53 which mediates cell cycle arrest), AR (37), AP-2alpha (38), Ik-2 (39), v-Myb[v-Myb motif enrichment in cell cycle gene promoters was previously shown in Ref. (40) and direct involvement in cell cycle was shown for a close relative c-Myb in Ref. (41)]. | • Rank-3 TM-2—(NF-Y E2F).These TFs are are known to interact (42). | • Of these, 150 include NF-Y, and 71 include both E2F and NF-Y. | ||
• (NF-Y AP-2) has a P-value = 1.1E−14. CDP and AP-2 function synergistically to regulate H3.2 during cell cycle and NF-Y and CDP bind to neighboring CAAT boxes in H3.2 promoter (43). | ||||
OPOSSUM2 | TM-2 | TM-3 | ||
• 20 significant (P ≤ 0.05) TM-2s. | oPOSSUM2 detected 33 size-3 TMs (64 by TREMOR). Surprisingly the | |||
• Only two include E2F, in combination with NF-Y and Gfi. Both combinations are detected by TREMOR. | three cell cycle regulators—E2F, NF-Y or CREB—were not included in any of the TMs returned by oPOSSUM2, while a majority of TREMOR TM-3s include these key TFs. | |||
• (CREB E2F) not detected. | ||||
• Only two TM-2s include NF-Y. | ||||
• In general, oPOSSUM detects fewer and more varied TMs while TREMOR TMs revolve around primary TFs- E2F, NF-Y and CREB. | ||||
CREME | • On our gene set, CREME yielded a total of two TM-3s—(AREB6, STAT4, TCF1P) and (SRY, STAT4, TCF1P, EGR). These do not include the three well-known cell cycle TFs—E2F, CREB and NFY. | |||
• CREME was applied to a slightly different cell cycle data in the original paper (19). CREME detected 47 TFs, compared to TREMOR's 41. CREME reports only seven significant non-redundant TMs. The three TM-2s are (ZF5 GR), (ZF5 HAND1E47) and (ZF5 USF2). The first two are detected by TREMOR. USF2 is an E-box TF and there are several TM-2s detected by TREMOR that link ZF5 with an E-box protein. The larger TMs detected by CREME were not detected by TREMOR. |
For oPOSSUM2 and CREME, the results are compared to TREMOR. Unless otherwise specified, for TREMOR we only mention the TMs whose P-values were lower than the lowest P-value for the corresponding randomly permuted set (see text).