Table 2.
TM-1 | TM-2 | TM-3,4,5 | |
---|---|---|---|
TREMOR | • 17 TM-1s detected—HNF-1, HNF-3alpha, STAT5A, GFI1B, IRF1, MEIS1A, AIRE, NF-AT, Pbx1b, HNF-4alpha1, POU3F2, NF-Y, MEF-2, AFP1, SRF, C/EBP, TCF-4. | • 31 TM-2s detected (however, not significant after multiple testing correction) | • 217, 224 and 266 TM-3s, TM-4s and TM-5s |
• Well-known liver TFs HNF1-3,4 and C/EBP are included among these. | • 1 involved HNF-3 and 25 involved HNF-1. | • 185, 222 and 266 involved HNF. | |
• 8 of the remaining 11 TFs have evidence of involvement in transcription in liver—STAT5 (44), GFI1b (45), IRF (46), Pbx1 (47), NF-Y (48), AFP1 (49), SRF (50) and Tcf-4 (51). | • Rank-1 TM-2 was (HNF-1 TATA). These TFs are known to interact (52). | ||
• TM-2s at rank 2, (HNF-1 HNF-4), and at rank 4, (HNF-1 NF-Y) are supported (53). | |||
OPOSSUM2 | TM-2 | TM-3 | |
• 3 TM-2s detected | • 31 TM-3s detected TMs, but none of them include FORKHEAD TFs, while 188 of 234 TREMOR TM-3s include FORKHEAD factors. | ||
• These combine zinc finger TF X2H2 with FoxA2, FoxD3 and FoxI1. | |||
• TREMOR detects many more TMs but 81 of the 226 include FORKHEAD factors. | |||
CREME | Even at the least stringent settings, namely, using the lowest matrix score threshold = 0.8 and the largest module length = 500 bp, as well as requiring only two TFs in the TM, CREME did not yield any TMs. |
For oPOSSUM2 and CREME, the results are compared to TREMOR. Unless otherwise specified, for TREMOR we only mention the TMs whose P-values were lower than the lowest P-value for the corresponding randomly permuted set (see text).