Predicted effects and cost of different strategies for preventing fracture in US white women with osteoporosis or osteopenia diagnosed by bone densitometry at hip or spine (mean age 72 years at baseline) and treated for 8.5 years (hip) and 3.7 years (spine)*
Treatment strategy and site of measurement | ||||||||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Basic cohort* | Treat if T score ≤ −2.5 | Treat if T score ≤−1.5 | Treat all | |||||||||||
Hip | Spine | Hip | Spine | Hip | Spine | Hip | Spine | |||||||
No of women | 8047 | 6892 | 1424 | 2274 | 3871 | 4108 | 8047 | 6892 | ||||||
% of population | 100 | 100 | 17.7 | 33 | 48.1 | 59.6 | 100 | 100 | ||||||
No of fractures in untreated women: | ||||||||||||||
Any non-spine | 2044 | — | 580 | — | 782 | — | 2044 | — | ||||||
Hip | 622 | — | 253 | — | 371 | — | 622 | — | ||||||
Spine | 389 | 361 | 149 | 213 | 191 | 230 | 389 | 361 | ||||||
No of fractures prevented by treatment†(% of fractures in basic cohort): | ||||||||||||||
Any non-spine | — | — | 290 (14) | — | 379 (19) | — | 505 (25) | — | ||||||
Hip | — | — | 127 (20) | — | 179 (29) | — | 204 (33) | — | ||||||
Spine | — | — | 75 (19) | 107 (29) | 93 (24) | 114 (32) | 113 (29) | 127 (35) | ||||||
Total cost of treatment ($m)‡ | — | — | 7.3 | 5.0 | 19.7 | 9.1 | 41.0 | 15.3 | ||||||
Cost ($)/prevented fracture: | ||||||||||||||
Any non-spine | — | — | 25 043 | — | 52 090 | — | 81 267 | — | ||||||
Hip | — | — | 57 184 | — | 110 291 | — | 201 175 | — | ||||||
Spine | — | — | 96 832 | 47 180 | 212 281 | 79 998 | 363 183 | 120 474 |
*Data derived from Stone et al11
† Assuming a best case scenario in which risk is reduced by 50% for all fractures in women with a T score below −2.5, by 44% for hip fracture and 20% for spine fracture in women with T score of −2.5 to −1.5, and by an estimated (in absence of data) 10% for women with a T score above −1.5.15 16
‡Based on an estimate of annual drug costs of $600 per patient with no costs attributed to bone densitometry, monitoring of treatment efficacy, or treating possible adverse events.