Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2008 Jan 23.
Published in final edited form as: Arch Gen Psychiatry. 2006 Nov;63(11):1217–1223. doi: 10.1001/archpsyc.63.11.1217

Table.

Characteristics of 28 RCTs Included in Primary and Secondary Analyses

Source SSRIs Used Randomization,
SSRI:Placebo, No.
Setting Severity
Criterion *
Notes
Wade et al,16 2002 Escitalopram 191:189 Primary care MADRS 22-40 None
Bech et al,28 2004 Escitalopram, citalopram 369:122 Outpatient MADRS (10) ≥22 Secondary analysis only
Gorman et al,29 2002 Escitalopram, citalopram 923:398 Outpatient MADRS ≥22 Data from 3 RCTs
Lepola et al,30 2003 Escitalopram, citalopram 315:154 Primary care MADRS 22-40 Secondary analysis only
Andreoli et al,31 2002 Fluoxetine 127:128 Inpatient and outpatient HDRS (21) ≥22 Secondary analysis only
Byerley et al,32 1988 Fluoxetine 32:29 Outpatient HDRS (21) ≥20 None
Feighner et al,14 1989 Fluoxetine 61:59 Outpatient HDRS (21) ≥20 None
Heiligenstein et al,33 1993 Fluoxetine 24:28 Outpatient NA Secondary analysis only
Rickels et al,34 1986 Fluoxetine 18:24 Outpatient HDRS ≥20 Secondary analysis only
Silverstone and Ravindran,35 1999 Fluoxetine 119:118 Outpatient HDRS(17) ≥20 None
Sramek et al,36 1995 Fluoxetine 72:72 Unclear HDRS (24) ≥21 Primary analysis only
Tollefson and Holman,15 1994 Fluoxetine 962:485 Unclear HDRS (21) ≥20 Data from 6 RCTs
Claghorn et al,13 1996 Fluvoxamine 50:50 Outpatient NA None
Dominguez et al,37 1985 Fluvoxamine 35:31 Outpatient HDRS (17) ≥15 Primary analysis only
Porro et al,38 1988 Fluvoxamine 21:20 Unclear HDRS ≥18 None
Roth et al,39 1990 Fluvoxamine 30:30 Outpatient HDRS(17) ≥22 Primary analysis only
Walczak et al,40 1996 Fluvoxamine 400:200 Outpatient HDRS ≥20 Secondary analysis only
Claghorn et al,41 1992 Paroxetine 170:171 Outpatient HDRS (17) ≥18 Secondary analysis only
Claghorn,42 1992 Paroxetine 36:36 Outpatient HDRS (17) ≥18 Primary analysis only
Edwards and Goldie,43 1993 Paroxetine 21:20 Outpatient HDRS (17) ≥16 None
Feighner et al,44 1993 Paroxetine 241:244 Outpatient HDRS (17) ≥18 Secondary analysis only
Data from 6 RCTs
Katz et al,45 2004 Paroxetine 28:25 Inpatient HDRS (21) ≥18 None
Kiev,46 1992 Paroxetine 38:40 Outpatient HDRS (17) ≥18 None
Smith and Glaudin,47 1992 Paroxetine 39:38 Unclear HDRS (17) ≥18 Primary analysis only
Trivedi et al,48 2004 Paroxetine CR 310:149 Outpatient HDRS (17) ≥20 None
Fabre et al,49 1995 Sertraline 278:91 Unclear HDRS (17) ≥22 None
Reimherr et al,50 1990 Sertraline 149:150 Outpatient HDRS (18) ≥18 None
Trivedi et al,51 2001 Sertraline 237:245 Outpatient HDRS (21) ≥18 Data from 2 RCTs Primary analysis only
Stahl,52 2000 Sertraline, citalopram 215:108 Unclear HDRS (17) ≥22 Secondary analysis only

Abbreviations: CR, controlled release; HDRS, Hamilton Depression Rating Scale; MADRS, Montgomery-Asberg Depression Rating Scale; NA, not available; RCT, randomized controlled trial; SSRI, selective serotonin reuptake inhibitor.

*

When trials required participants to reach specified scores on the HDRS or the MADRS for inclusion, these scores are noted immediately following the scale. Numbers in parentheses refer to the number of items on the scale.