Table 1.
Summary of Potential Treatment Strategies and Their Effectiveness for Hypercapnic CSA*
Variables | Intervention | Benefits | Limitations | Level of Evidence |
---|---|---|---|---|
OHS (won’t breathe) | Weight loss | Likely ↓ in SDB and other health-related benefits | Difficult to achieve | No published data in this population |
CPAP | Variable ↓ in SDB; ↑ QOL | Not effective for all patients | Several small, short-term non- RCTs73–75 | |
Bilevel PAP/bilevel PAP plus backup mode | Normalizes AHI; ↑QOL; ↑ Pao2; ↓Paco2 | Long-term effectiveness unknown | Several, small, short-term non- RCTs73,76 and one small RCT77 | |
O2 | May ↓ hypoventilation in certain patients | Very limited data available | Case report78 | |
Progesterone | May improve daytime gas exchange; ↑ hypercapnic chemoresponsiveness | Effects on AHI unknown in this population and no long- term safety data | One small, moderate-term non- RCT79 | |
Narcotic-induced CSA (can’t breathe) | Dose reduction | Likely ↓ in SDB | Difficult to achieve | Case report (Fig 2) |
Impaired respiratory motor control | Bilevel PAP | Likely ↓ in SDB | Limited data available, and patient tolerance may be poor | Several non-RCTs (refer to Malhotra et al5 and Schneerson et al76 for detail) |
PAP = positive airway pressure; QOL = quality of life; RCT = randomized control trial; ↑ = increase; ↓ = decrease.