Table 1.
Results of the Repeated Measures ANOVA Models Testing for Differential Change Across Conditions on the Beck Depression Inventory
Waitlist control |
CBT |
Supportive-expressive |
Bibliotherapy |
Expressive writing |
|||||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
F(df) | p | r | F(df) | p | r | F(df) | p | r | F(df) | p | r | F(df) | p | r | |
CBT | |||||||||||||||
- Pre to post | 34.81(1,115) | .001 | .48 | ||||||||||||
- Pre to 1 mo | 9.90(1,115) | .002 | .28 | ||||||||||||
- Pre to 6 mo | 2.63(1,115) | .107 | .15 | ||||||||||||
Supportive-expressive | |||||||||||||||
- Pre to post | 31.28(1,84) | .001 | .52 | 0.36(1,67) | .549 | .07 | |||||||||
- Pre to 1 mo | 3.30(1,84) | .073 | .19 | 0.22(1,67) | .642 | .05 | |||||||||
- Pre to 6 mo | 2.99(1,84) | .088 | .18 | 0.45(1,67) | .502 | .08 | |||||||||
Bibliotherapy | |||||||||||||||
- Pre to post | 14.93(1,93) | .001 | .37 | 0.73(1,76) | .395 | .10 | 1.52(1,45) | .224 | .18 | ||||||
- Pre to 1 mo | 3.06(1,93) | .084 | .18 | 0.72(1,76) | .399 | .09 | 0.07(1,45) | .786 | .04 | ||||||
- Pre to 6 mo | 8.70(1.93) | .004 | .29 | 3.06(1,76) | .084 | .19 | 0.52(1,45) | .475 | .10 | ||||||
Expressive writing | |||||||||||||||
- Pre to post | 17.37(1,92) | .001 | .40 | 0.97(1,75) | .328 | .11 | 2.27(1,44) | .139 | .22 | .003(1,53) | .956 | .00 | |||
- Pre to 1 mo | 1.14(1,92) | .288 | .11 | 2.11(1,75) | .151 | .16 | 0.60(1,44) | .442 | .11 | 0.31(1,53) | .581 | .08 | |||
- Pre to 6 mo | 0.01(1,92) | .930 | .00 | 1.84(1,75) | .179 | .15 | 2.24(1,44) | .141 | .22 | 6.32(1,53) | .015 | .32 | |||
Journaling | |||||||||||||||
- Pre to post | 8.98(1,99) | .003 | .29 | 4.50(1,82) | .037 | .23 | 5.92(1,44) | .018 | .32 | 0.95(1,60) | .335 | .13 | 1.06(1,59) | .308 | .13 |
- Pre to 1 mo | 2.50(1,99) | .117 | .16 | 1.72(1,82) | .194 | .14 | 0.38(1,44) | .543 | .08 | 0.11(1,60) | .746 | .04 | 0.10(1,59) | .759 | .04 |
- Pre to 6 mo | 1.19(1.99) | .279 | .11 | 0.06(1,82) | .803 | .03 | 0.53(1,44) | .469 | .10 | 2.70(1,60) | .106 | .21 | 0.85(1,59) | .360 | .12 |
Note: Significant effects are shown in bold font.