Table 1.
Study | No women* (No analysed) | Patient status of women | Type of hypertensive disorder of pregnancy included | Gestational age (weeks) | Exclusions | QUADAS score |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Al et al 2004w1 | 221 (185) | Inpatients | Gestational hypertension | ≥29 | Urinary tract infection or chronic medical illness,* severe hypertension | 11 |
Durnwald et al 2003w2 | 220 | Inpatients | Suspected pre-eclampsia (gestational hypertension, oedema, or new + or more proteinuria)† | ≥24 | Chronic medical illness* | 9 |
Jaschevatzky et al 1990w3 | 35 | Inpatients | Pre-eclampsia (gestational hypertension, oedema, or new proteinuria) | ≥29 | NS | 8 |
Neithardt et al 2002w4 | 36 (30) | Inpatients | Any hypertensive disorder of pregnancy (81%), type I diabetes or nephropathy | Any | NS | 8 |
Ramos et al 1999w5 | 47 | Inpatients | Gestational hypertension | >20 | Chronic medical illness,* multiple pregnancy, preterm, prelabour rupture of membranes, stillbirth, or absent fetus | 9 |
Robert et al 1997w6 | 71 | Inpatients | Gestational hypertension | ≥24 | Bacteriuria or diuretic use | 9 |
Rodriguez-Thompson et al 2001w7 | 138 | NS | Any hypertensive disorder of pregnancy, diabetes mellitus (3%) | ≥29 | Urinary tract infection or chronic medical illness* | 9 |
Saudan et al 1997w8 | 100 | Inpatients and outpatients | Any hypertensive disorder of pregnancy | NS | NS | 7 |
Taherian et al 2006w9 | 100 | NS | Suspected pre-eclampsia (gestational hypertension, ≥160/110 mm Hg, + or more proteinuria or oedema) | >20 | Urinary tract infection, chronic medical illness,* or haematuria | 11 |
Valerio et al 2005w10 | 85 (75) | Inpatients | Gestational hypertension | >20 | Stillbirth, prelabour rupture of membranes, gestational age ≥41 weeks | 12 |
Wheeler et al 2007w11 | 154 (126) | Inpatients | Suspected pre-eclampsia (gestational hypertension, worsening hypertension, or + or more proteinuria) | >20 | Bacteriuria, bed rest for more than 24 hours | 11 |
Yamasmit et al 2004w12 | 55 (42) | Inpatients | Suspected pre-eclampsia (gestational or pre-existing hypertension with new + or more proteinuria) | ≥29 | Urinary tract infection or chronic medical illness* | 12 |
Young et al 1996w13 | 66 (45) | Inpatients | Gestational hypertension | ≥29 | Previous diagnosis of “pregnancy induced hypertension,” or bed rest at home or in hospital for more than 36 hours | 10 |
QUADAS=quality assessment of studies of diagnostic accuracy in systematic reviews based on 14 criteria of study quality; NS=not specified.
*Including chronic (pre-existing) hypertension, pregestational diabetes mellitus, or chronic renal disease.
†Women who were post partum or had vaginal bleeding of another cause and had urine collected through a urinary catheter.