Table 1.
Reference | Randomisation stated | Double blinding | Dropout and withdrawals | Generation of random numbers | Allocation concealment | Score (0-5) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
PEPI 1995w12 | Yes | Yes | 3.0% dropout, 3.0% withdrawal | Computer generated block | Active drug and placebo in identical forms | 5 |
HERS 1998w13 | Yes | Yes | 0% dropout, 2.1% withdrawal | Computer generated | Active drug and placebo in identical forms | 5 |
EVTET 2000w14 | Yes | Yes | 23.6% dropout, 23.6% withdrawal | Computer generated block | Active drug and placebo in identical forms | 5 |
ERA 2000w15 | Yes | Yes | 14.0% dropout, 4.0% withdrawal | Permuted block | Each woman received two tablets (active and placebo or two placebo) | 5 |
WEST 2001w16 | Yes | Yes | 0% dropout, 1.4% withdrawal | Computer generated block | ? | 4 |
ESPRIT 2002w17 | Yes | Yes | Not available | Computer generated block | Active drug and placebo in identical forms | 4 |
WHI I 2002w18 | Yes | Yes | 3.5% dropout | Permuted block | Active drug and placebo in identical forms | 5 |
WHI II 2004w19 | Yes | Yes | 2.2% dropout, 3.0% withdrawal | Permuted block | Active drug and placebo in identical forms | 5 |
WISDOM 2007w20 | Yes | Yes | 0.01% dropout, 13.2% withdrawal | Computer generated block | Active drug and placebo in identical forms | 5 |
Appropriate=1; No information or not appropriate=0.