Skip to main content
. 2008 May 20;336(7655):1227–1231. doi: 10.1136/bmj.39555.441944.BE

Table 1.

 Quality assessment of included randomised controlled trials on hormone replacement therapy that reported venous thromboembolism

Reference Randomisation stated Double blinding Dropout and withdrawals Generation of random numbers Allocation concealment Score (0-5)
PEPI 1995w12 Yes Yes 3.0% dropout, 3.0% withdrawal Computer generated block Active drug and placebo in identical forms 5
HERS 1998w13 Yes Yes 0% dropout, 2.1% withdrawal Computer generated Active drug and placebo in identical forms 5
EVTET 2000w14 Yes Yes 23.6% dropout, 23.6% withdrawal Computer generated block Active drug and placebo in identical forms 5
ERA 2000w15 Yes Yes 14.0% dropout, 4.0% withdrawal Permuted block Each woman received two tablets (active and placebo or two placebo) 5
WEST 2001w16 Yes Yes 0% dropout, 1.4% withdrawal Computer generated block ? 4
ESPRIT 2002w17 Yes Yes Not available Computer generated block Active drug and placebo in identical forms 4
WHI I 2002w18 Yes Yes 3.5% dropout Permuted block Active drug and placebo in identical forms 5
WHI II 2004w19 Yes Yes 2.2% dropout, 3.0% withdrawal Permuted block Active drug and placebo in identical forms 5
WISDOM 2007w20 Yes Yes 0.01% dropout, 13.2% withdrawal Computer generated block Active drug and placebo in identical forms 5

Appropriate=1; No information or not appropriate=0.