Skip to main content
. 2007 Winter;16(Suppl 1):10S–19S. doi: 10.1624/105812407X173137

Access to Birth Companions

Rationale for Compliance
Evidence Grade
No evidence of medical harm found for: NEH
 • unrestricted access by mother to birth companions
 • access of mother to companions of her choice
 • fathers at birth
 • partners at birth
 • children at birth
 • family members at birth
 • friends at birth
Mothers reported less satisfaction with birth support when the support provider was a nurse or a doctor compared with a partner or doula (trained or experienced woman who provides continuous labor support) (DeClercq, 2002). Quality: A
Quantity: B
Consistency: NA*
The perception of support during labor is a key ingredient in a woman's ultimate satisfaction with her birth experience (Hodnett, 2002). Quality: A
Quantity: A
Consistency: A**
The perception of support during labor is more important in determining a woman's satisfaction with her birth experience than her experience of pain or her satisfaction with methods of pain relief (Hodnett, 2002). Quality: A
Quantity: A
Consistency: A**

A = good, B = fair, NA = not applicable, NEH = no evidence of harm

Quality = aggregate of quality ratings for individual studies

Quantity = magnitude of effect, numbers of studies, and sample size or power

Consistency = the extent to which similar findings are reported using similar and different study designs

*

only one study

**

multiple studies in systematic review (SR)