TABLE 7.
Study | Ethnicity | Treatment & Problem | Culture-Responsive Elements |
---|---|---|---|
Clark et al. (1998) | African American | FIAP for abused youth with emotional and behavioral problems | Therapists used client's strengths across multiple life domains, including “cultural/ethnic/spiritual interests and involvement” |
Fantuzzo et al. (2005) | African American | Resilient Peer Modeling for socially withdrawn, maltreated youth | Treatment was “culturally appropriate” in its use of family volunteers and socially high-functioning peers, with common cultural backgrounds and experiences |
Garza & Bratton (2005) | Mexican American | Child-Centered Play Therapy for behavior problems | Bilingual Hispanic counselors, with counselors responding “in-kind” to youth language preference. Selection of multicultural toys to “capture elements of Hispanic culture” |
Ginsburg & Drake (2002) | African American | Group CBT for anxiety disorders | Manual adapted to be “culturally sensitive (e.g., examples changed, alternative situations used, etc.)” |
Henggeler, Melton, & Smith (1992) | African American | MST for serious and chronic antisocial behavior | Individualized treatment plans and assessment of multiple contexts, allows MST to “deal flexibly with sociocultural differences in adolescents' psychosocial contexts” |
Henggeler, Pickrel, & Brondino (1999) | African American | MST for substance-abusing and dependent, delinquent youth | Two thirds of counselors African American (but unclear if therapist–client ethnic match) |
Hudley & Graham (1993) | African American | Attributional Intervention for aggressive youth | Treatment conducted by African American females |
Huey & Rank (1984) | African American | Counselor- & peer-led Assertive Training for aggressive youth | Peer and professional counselors were Black. Also, unspecified “adaptations for cultural differences incorporated” into intervention |
Liddle et al. (2004) | Primarily African American & Hispanic | Multidimensional Family Therapy for substance use problems | 86% of therapists were either Hispanic or Black (but unclear if therapist–client ethnic match) |
Lochman, Curry, Dane, & Ellis (2001) | African American | Coping Power (Anger Coping Program) | African American staff involved in development of intervention; in group sessions, participants encouraged to discuss what they already do that works, and those efforts are then used as positive examples; act collaboratively with participants as coaches rather than as teachers |
Rossello & Bernal (1999) | Latino (Puerto Rican) | CBT for depression; IPT for depression | IPT and CBT “adapted, taking into consideration cultural aspects of the treatments that consider the ‘interpersonal’ aspects of the Latino culture” |
Rossello, Bernal, & Rivera-Medina (in press) | Latino (Puerto Rican) | CBT for depression; IPT for depression | Both CBT and IPT were culturally adapted “based on a framework that employs criteria of ecological validity” |
Rowland et al. (2005) | Multiracial Hawaiian (combinations of Asian, Pacific Islander, and Caucasian) | MST for serious emotional and behavioral problems | Cultural background of clinical team representative of client population. Use of “Family Resource Specialist” to “help families develop indigenous social supports and to assist the clinical team in understanding the cultures and contexts in which the families were embedded” |
Silverman et al. (1999) | Latino | Group CBT for anxiety disorders | Therapist training involved “sensitizing therapists to issues specific to working with multicultural populations, such as cultural differences in modes of coping, definitions of anxiety-provoking objects or events, and particular parenting styles” |
Stein et al. (2003) | Latino (children of Mexican immigrants) | Group CBT for PTSD symptoms | Intervention “designed for use…with a multicultural population” |
Szapocznik, Santisteban et al. (1989) | Latino | FET for behavioral and psychological complaints | Treatment addressed intergenerational, cultural conflict. Counselors Hispanic and experience working with Hispanics |
Note: CBT = Cognitive Behavioral Therapy; FET = Family Effectiveness Therapy; FIAP = Fostering Individualized Assistance Program; IPT = Interpersonal Psychotherapy; MST = Multisystemic Therapy; PTSD = Posttraumatic Stress Disorder.