Skip to main content
. 2008 Jun 17;105(25):8531–8536. doi: 10.1073/pnas.0710477105

Table 1.

Summary of simulation results and sensitivity analysis

Pumping scenario Domestic well depth, m Pumping rate Kh, m/s Kh/Kv Primary criteria
Secondary criterion
As safe, %* Long travel time, % Low lift, %
Pumping strategy variation
    Predevelopment 175§ 5 × 10−4 104 60 94 100
    Predevelopment 225§ 5 × 10−4 104 64 94 100
    Shallow 10–50 Base case 5 × 10−4 104 0.5 0 78
    Deep 150–200 Base case 5 × 10−4 104 13 7 30
    Split 150–200 Base case 5 × 10−4 104 42 84 71
    Deep 200–250 Base case 5 × 10−4 104 17 13 18
    Split 200–250 Base case 5 × 10−4 104 45 90 73
    Split 110–150 Base case 5 × 10−4 104 34 54 71
Parameter variation
    Split 150–200 Base case 5 × 10−4 103 24 47 100
    Split 150–200 Base case 5 × 10−4 105 21 90 0
    Split 150–200 Base case 5 × 10−3 104 65 49 100
    Split 150–200 Base case 8 × 10−4 1.6 × 103 50 81 96
    Split 150–200 Base case 2 × 10−4 2 × 104 22 87 0
    Split 150–200 Base case 8 × 10−4 8 × 104 28 90 0
    Split 150–200 Base case 2 × 10−4 2.2 × 103 29 76 98
    Split 150–200 Base case 8 × 10−4 103 49 77 99
    Split 200–250 Base case 5 × 10−4 103 24 58 100
    Split 200–250 Base case 5 × 10−4 105 25 94 0
Pumping rate variation
    Split 150–200 Half-domestic 5 × 10−4 104 42 89 76
    Split 150–200 Double-domestic 5 × 10−4 104 37 59 60
    Split 150–200 Half-irrigation 5 × 10−4 104 49 88 99
    Split 150–200 Double-irrigation 5 × 10−4 104 31 63 35
    Deep 150–200 No irrigation 5 × 10−4 104 50 90 100

Percentage of area within the high-arsenic region for which:

*Sustainability criterion: recharge locations for wells are outside of the region.

Travel time criterion: water takes >1,000 years after recharging to reach wells.

Lift criterion: there is an acceptable lift (<12 m) in the domestic well zone.

§Maximum depth at end of flow path.