Skip to main content
. 2007 Jun;16(3):208–212. doi: 10.1136/qshc.2006.019539

Table 3 Patients' risk: general practitioners' assessment in comparison with Mellibase‐calculated values (one‐sample statistics; t test).

n Doctors' estimates SD SEM Calculated value (MB) Overestimation by doctors against MB values (%) Mean difference (test–reference) 95% CI of the difference p Value
Patient 1
 Myocardial infarction 150 61.580 25.542 2.086 34.9 76 26.680 22.559 to 30.801 0.000*
 Amputation 149 38.195 25.705 2.106 26.6 44 11.595 7.433 to 15.756 0.000*
 Blindness 149 30.872 25.307 2.073 7.1 335 23.773 19.676 to 27.869 0.000*
 Renal failure 149 35.664 25.432 2.086 0.6 5844 35.064 30.947 to 39.182 0.000*
 Stroke 150 48.653 25.220 2.059 8.9 447 39.753 35.684 to 43.822 0.000*
Patient 2
 Myocardial infarction 149 42.946 24.604 2.016 32.2 33 10.746 6.763 to 14.729 0.000*
 Amputation 149 18.023 18.745 1.536 21.4 −16 −3.377 −6.411 to −0.342 0.029**
 Blindness 149 13.621 16.216 1.329 0.3 4440 13.321 10.696 to 15.946 0.000*
 Renal failure 149 17.148 18.566 1.521 0.8 2044 16.348 13.342 to 19.353 0.000*
 Stroke 149 38.389 24.966 2.045 24.0 60 14.389 10.347 to 18.431 0.000*
Patient 3
 Myocardial infarction. 150 54.533 27.353 2.233 13.4 307 41.133 36.720 to 45.546 0.000*
 Amputation 150 36.420 25.892 2.114 6.9 428 29.520 25.343 to 33.697 0.000*
 Blindness 150 32.360 25.695 2.098 4.9 560 27.460 23.314 to 31.606 0.000*
 Renal failure 150 42.833 28.646 2.339 22.7 89 20.133 15.512 to 24.755 0.000*
 Stroke 150 48.367 26.840 2.192 8.8 450 39.567 35.236 to 43.897 0.000*
Patient 4
 Myocardial infarction 150 52.220 24.821 2.027 24.9 110 27.320 23.315 to 31.325 0.000*
 Amputation 149 31.537 23.528 1.928 9.8 222 21.737 17.928 to 25.546 0.000*
 Blindness 150 27.780 23.770 1.941 5.0 456 22.780 18.945 to 26.615 0.000*
 Renal failure 150 37.640 26.866 2.194 11.5 227 26.140 21.805 to 30.475 0.000*
 Stroke 150 47.780 26.573 2.170 9.1 425 38.680 34.393 to 42.967 0.000*

MB, Mellibase.

*p<0.01, highly significant; **p<0.05, significant.