Table 2.
Study | No of patients | Inclusion criteria | Important exclusion criteria | Medication | Duration of treatment (wk) | Outcome measure for symptoms | Significant difference between PPI and placebo |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Havas (1999) | 15 | Symptoms and laryngoscopic signs of LPR | Pre-existing anti-secretory medication, severe oesophagitis at endoscopy | Lansoprazole 30 mg bd | 12 | Significant reduction in mean composite symptom score | No |
Noordzij (2001) | 30 | Symptoms of LPR for min 3 months and abnormal result of hypopharyngeal pH monitoring | Infection, cancer, allergies | Omeprazole 40 mg bd | 8 | Significant reduction in mean composite symptom score | No |
El-Serag (2001) | 22 | Symptoms for ≥3 wks and laryngoscopic signs of LPR | Infection, cancer, allergies | Lansoprazole 30 mg bd | 12 | Complete symptom resolution | Yes? |
Eherer (2003) | 21 | Hoarseness for ≥8 wks and laryngoscopic signs of LPR | Smokers | Pantoprazole 40 mg bd | 12 | Significant reduction in mean composite symptom score | No |
Steward (2004) | 42 | Symptoms for ≥4 wks and laryngoscopic signs of LPR | Current or recent (within 1 mth) use of H2RA or PPI | Rabeprazole 20 mg bd | 8 | Significant improvement in mean composite symptom score | No |
Wo (2006) | 39 | Symptoms and laryngoscopic signs of LPR. Abnormal triple- sensor pH monitoring | Previous treatment of GERD | Pantoprazole 20 mg od | 12 | Patient reported global adequate relief of symptoms | No |
Vaezi (2006) | 146 | Laryngeal symptoms for ≥12 wks and laryngoscopic signs of LPR | Moderate to severe heartburn in 3 weeks prior to enrollment | Esomeprazole 40 mg bd | 16 | Resolution of most bothersome symptom | No |
Abbreviations: GERD, gastro-oesophageal reflux disease; LPR, laryngopharyngeal reflux; PPI, proton pump inhibitor.