Table 13.
Free energies of solvation, kcal/mol
Alcohol | CHARMM22 | Drude | Exp | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
LRCa | ΔGsolv | %diff | LRCa | ΔGuncorr | ΔGsolv | %diff | ΔGsolv | |
MeOH | −0.20 | −4.98 (0.08) | −3 | −0.26 | −5.20 (0.19) | −4.64 (0.18) | −9 | −5.11b |
EtOH | −0.31 | −5.34 (0.12) | 7 | −0.35 | −5.66 (0.31) | −4.97 (0.13) | −1 | −5.01b |
2-PrOH | −0.39 | −5.07 (0.09) | 7 | −0.45 | −6.06 (0.23) | −4.82 (0.16) | 1 | −4.76b |
2-BuOH | −0.45 | −4.93 (0.27) | 8 | −0.57 | −6.11 (0.18) | −4.75 (0.43) | 4 | −4.57c |
1-PrOH | −0.42 | −5.33 (0.24) | 10 | −0.46 | −5.38 (0.16) | −4.85 (0.15) | 0 | −4.83b |
1-BuOH | −0.53 | −5.60 (0.21) | 19 | −0.57 | −5.72 (0.16) | −4.67 (0.23) | −1 | −4.72b |
Aver | 9 | −1 |
The long range correction (LRC) is estimated for dispersion forces. In the polarizable model, ΔGuncorr represents free energy obtained using standard combining rule for intermolecular LJ interactions and ΔGsolv is free energy that included an off-diagonal (i.e. NBFIX) for the Oalcohol…Owater LJ parameters (Rmin=3.60, ε=0.18 for primary alcohols, and Rmin=3.60, ε=0.21 for secondary alcohols).
Experimental results as reported in reference 92
reference.93