TABLE 1.
Agent | Neurotransmitter | Study design | Number of studies | Main results |
Bromocriptine | Dopamine | Single cases Case series Open-label RCT | 11 | Positive effects in open label studies mainly in transcortical motor aphasia and a dynamic aphasia of moderate severity. Improvement in overall aphasia severity in chronic patients. Variable outcomes in Broca's aphasia. Lack of efficacy in severe cases. Various RCTs negative. |
Piracetam | GABA, Excitatory aminoacids | RCT | 7 | Positive effects in the acute stage in overall language measures, spontaneous speech and written language. Lack of efficacy in chronic stages. |
Donepezil | Acetylcholine | Single cases Case series Open label RCT | 6 | Positive effects in global aphasia severity, communication, spontaneous speech, comprehension, naming and speed and accuracy of information processing. Efficacy maintained at long-term follow-up. |
Dexanfetamine | Norepinephrine Dopamine Serotonine | Open-label RCT Single-case RCT | 3 | Positive effect in overall performance on communication in subacute stages with efficacy maintained at chronic stages. Negative effect in anomia in a single-subject RCT. |
Bifemelane | Acetylcholine | RCT | 1 | Positive effect on anomia. |
Fluvoxamine | Serotonine | Crossover | 1 | Positive effect on anomia, perseverations and mood in fluent aphasia. |
Moclobemide | Serotonine Norepinephrine Dopamine | RCT | 1 | Negative effect. |
Zolpidem | GABA | Single case | 1 | Positive effect, transient effect on verbal output |
Notes: Only agents with a theoretically-driven rationale to be used in the treatment of aphasia were included. Other agents (e.g., haloperidol, propranolol, thiazide diuretics, chlordiazepoxide) lacking scientific justification were excluded. GABA indicates γ aminobutyric acid; RCT = randomised controlled trial. See further details and references of pharmacological studies in Berthier, 2005; Shisler et al., 2000; Small, 2004.