Skip to main content
. 2006 Jun;15(3):242–246. doi: 10.1136/tc.2005.015479

Table 3 Prevalence (%) of respiratory symptoms among workers in the hospitality industry before and after the smoking ban.

Before smoking ban After smoking ban Difference McNemar*
Morning Smokers 28.5 25.9 −2.6 0.29
cough Non‐smokers 10.6 4.9 −5.8 <0.01
Former smokers 20.8 2.1 −18.8 0.00
Daytime Smokers 28.9 32.0 3.1 0.24
cough Non‐smokers 14.9 7.3 −7.6 <0.01
Former smokers 27.1 8.3 −18.8 0.01
Phlegm Smokers 18.3 17.4 −0.9 0.74
cough Non‐smokers 9.8 5.2 −4.6 0.01
Former smokers 20.8 4.2 −16.7 0.02
Dyspnoea Smokers 25.4 19.8 −5.7 0.01
Non‐smokers 10.7 5.2 −5.5 <0.01
Former smokers 20.8 6.3 −14.6 0.07
Wheezing Smokers 12.4 12.4 0.0 1.00
Non‐smokers 4.3 2.7 −1.5 0.36
Former smokers 14.6 0.0 −14.6 0.02
Any Smokers 50.1 48.2 −2.0 0.49
symptom Non‐smokers 26.4 14.6 −11.9 <0.01
Former smokers 50.0 16.7 33.3 <0.01

*Exact McNemar significance probability.