Table 2.
Authors | Date of publication | Number of evaluated UKAs | Type of implant | Number of surgeons | Mean followup (years)* | Survivorship (number of revisions) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Medial UKA | ||||||
Marmor [23] | 1986 | 53 | Cemented all poly tibia | 1 | 11 (10–13) | 70% at 10 years (20) |
Squire et al. [34] | 1999 | 48 | Cemented all poly tibia | 1 | 18 (15.8–21.8) | 84% at 22 years (5) |
Argenson et al. [2] | 2002 | 145 | Cemented, metal-backed, fixed-bearing | 2 | 5.5 (3–9.33) | 94% at 10 years (5) |
Perkins and Gunckle [31] | 2002 | 40 | Cemented, metal-backed (60%); all poly (40%) | 1 | 6 (3–10) | 74% at 10 years (6) |
Gioe et al. [16] | 2003 | 474 | Nine different designs | 23 | NA | 88.6% at 10 years (36) |
Naudie et al. [25] | 2004 | 113 | Cemented, metal-backed, fixed-bearing | NA | 10 (2–14) | 86 % at 10 years (11) |
Berger et al. [6] | 2005 | 62 | Cemented, metal-backed, fixed-bearing | 3 | 12 (10–13) | 95.7 % at 13years (2) |
O’Rourke et al. [26] | 2005 | 122 | Cemented all poly tibia | 1 | 24 (17–28) | 72% at 25 years (17) |
Eickmann et al. [10] | 2006 | 411 | 12 different designs | 1 | 9 (0.1–19.3) | 80% at 9 years (96) |
Lateral UKA | ||||||
Marmor [22] | 1983 | 14 | Cemented all poly tibia | 1 | 7.4 (2.5–9.83) | NA (2) |
Gunther et al. [17] | 1996 | 53 | Cemented, metal-backed, mobile-bearing | 2 | 5 (2.5–9.83) | 82% at 5 years (11) |
Ohdera et al. [27] | 2001 | 18 | Four different designs | NA | 8.25 (5–15.75) | NA (2) |
Ashraf et al. [5] | 2002 | 83 | Cemented all poly tibia | 4 | 9 (2–21) | 74% at 15years (15) |
O’Rourke et al. [26] | 2005 | 14 | Cemented all poly tibia | 1 | 24 (17–28) | 72% at 25 years (2) |
Pennington et al. [30] | 2006 | 29 | Cemented, metal-backed (75%); all poly tibia (25%) | NA | 12.4 (3.1–15.6) | 100% at 12.4 years (0) |
Sah and Scott [32] | 2007 | 49 | Three different designs | 1 | 5.2 (2–14) | 100% at 5.4 years (0) |
Our series | 38 | Four different designs | 2 | 12.6 (3–23) | 84% at 16 years (5) |
* Ranges in parentheses; UKA = unicondylar knee arthroplasty; NA = not available.