Skip to main content
. 2008 Oct 19;9:142. doi: 10.1186/1471-2474-9-142

Table 1.

Checklist used for the assessment of clinimetric properties of the studies included in the review

Clinimetric property Definition Criteria
Reproducibility
Degree to which repeated measurements in stable persons provide similar answers K: nominal/ordinal data
ICC: ordinal/parametric data
 Reliability
The extent to which patients can be distinguished from each other, despite measurement error + Adequate design, method; intraobserver ICC > 0.85 or K > 0.41; interobserver ICC >0.70 or K>0.61
± Information unclear or method doubtful
- Adequate design, method; intraobserver ICC < 0.85 or K < 0.40; interobserver ICC < 0.70 or K < 0.60
? No information found
 Agreement
The ability to achieve the same value with repeated measurements Limits of agreement, SEM or SDC are presented
+ Sufficient information, bias unlikely
± Information unclear or method doubtful
- Information sufficient, instrument did not meet criteria
? No information

Construct validity
The extent to which a test actually measures the concept or trait which is being measured Pearson's R or Spearman Rho
+ Adequate design, method; r >0.65
± Information unclear or method doubtful
- Information sufficient, instrument did not meet criteria
? No information

Responsiveness
Ability of an instrument to detect important change over time in the concept being measured Hypotheses were formulated and results are in agreement
+ Adequate design, method; intraobserver ICC > 0.85 or K > 0.41; interobserver ICC >0.70 or K>0.61
± Information unclear or method doubtful
- Adequate design, method; intraobserver ICC < 0.85 or K < 0.40; interobserver ICC < 0.70 or K < 0.60
? No information

Interpretability
The degree to which one can assign qualitative meaning to quantitative scores Authors provided information on the interpretation of scores, MIC-defined Mean and SD scores before and after treatment

* K = Kappa statistics; ICC = intraclass correlation coefficient, SEM = standard error of measurement, SDC = smallest detectable change, MIC = minimal important change, and SD = standard deviation