Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2008 Oct 29.
Published in final edited form as: J Law Med Ethics. 2008;36(2):219–211. doi: 10.1111/j.1748-720X.2008.00266.x

Table 5.

Recommended Classification of Incidental Findings

Category Relevant IFs Recommended Action
Strong Net Benefit
  • information revealing a condition likely to be life-threatening

  • information revealing a condition likely to be grave that can be avoided or ameliorated

  • genetic information revealing significant risk of a condition likely to be life-threatening

  • genetic information that can be used to avoid or ameliorate a condition likely to be grave

  • genetic information that can be used in reproductive decision-making: (1) to avoid significant risk for offspring of a condition likely to be life-threatening or grave or (2) to ameliorate a condition likely to be life-threatening or grave

  • Disclose to research participant as an incidental finding, unless s/he elected not to know.

Possible Net Benefit
  • information revealing a nonfatal condition that is likely to be grave or serious but that cannot be avoided or ameliorated, when a research participant is likely to deem that information important

  • genetic information revealing significant risk of a condition likely to be grave or serious, when that risk cannot be modified but a research participant is likely to deem that information important

  • genetic information that is likely to be deemed important by a research participant and can be used in reproductive decision-making: (1) to avoid significant risk for offspring of a condition likely to be serious or (2) to ameliorate a condition likely to be serious

  • May disclose to research participant as an incidental findings, unless s/he elected not to know.

Unlikely Net Benefit
  • information revealing a condition that is not likely to be of serious health or reproductive importance

  • information whose likely health or reproductive importance cannot be ascertained

  • Do not disclose to research participant as an incidental finding.