Table 1. Published meta-analyses in multiple tumour types.
Tumour type | Studies included | Reference | Relationship analysed | Number of studies | Slope coefficient | R 2 |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Breast: metastatic | All randomised studies reporting progression and survival times by treatment | Current analysis | Ratio of median progression and ratio of median survival times (centred at zero) | 67 | 0.32 | 0.30 |
Breast: metastatic | Studies of anthracyclines and taxanes with individual patient data | Burzykowski et al (2008) | Log hazard ratio for progression and log hazard ratio for survival | 11 | Not provided | 0.23 |
Breast: metastatic | Studies of epirubicin regimens with individual patient data | Bruzzi et al (2005) | Log hazard ratio for response and log odds ratio for survival | 10 | Not provided | 0.10 |
Breast: advanced | Studies of first-line treatments using FAC or FEC | Hackshaw et al (2005) | Log hazard ratio for time-to-progression and log hazard ratio for survival | 17 before 1990 | 0.58 before 1990 | 0.67 before 1990 |
9 after 1990 | 0.40 after 1990 | 0.41 after 1990 | ||||
Breast: adjuvant | Studies reporting 2- to 3-year disease-free survival and 5-year overall survival (N⩾100) | Ng et al (2008) | Difference in proportion with disease-free survival at 2 years and difference in proportion surviving >5 years | 126 | Not provided | 0.38 |
Colorectal: advanced | Studies of FU+leucovorin with individual patient data | Buyse et al (2007) | Log hazard ratio for progression- free survival and log hazard ratio for survival | 10 | 0.81 | 0.98 |
Colorectal: metastatic | Studies with ‘mature data’ (N⩾100) | Tang et al (2007) | Hazard ratio for progression and hazard ratio for survival | 39 | Not provided | 0.55 (PFS) 0.27 (TTP) |
Colorectal: metastatic | Studies of first-line treatments | Johnson et al (2006) | Difference in months-to-progression and difference in survival months | 146 | 0.096 | 0.33 |
Colorectal: metastatic | Studies of first-line treatments (N⩾100 per arm) | Louvet et al (2001) | Median months progression-free survival and median months survival by treatment group | 29 | 0.68 | 0.23 |
Colon: adjuvant | Studies selected based on ‘relevance, maturity and data availability’ (individual patient data) | Sargent et al (2005) | Hazard ratio for disease-free survival and hazard ratio for survival | 18 | 0.89 | 0.90 |
Lung (non-small-cell) | Studies reporting hazard ratios since 1977 | Johnson et al (2004) | Log hazard ratio for time-to-progression and log hazard ratio for survival | 48 | Not provided | 0.42 |
Lung: metastatic | Studies of first-line treatments | Johnson et al (2006) | Difference in months-to-progression and difference in survival months | 191 | 0.62 | 0.19 |
R2=coefficient of determination for multivariate analysis or derived as squared correlation coefficient.