Table 1.
Comparison of AMMP optimization methods for small molecules minimized with sp4 and sp5 force fields
Optimization methods | ||||||||||||
Compound | Initial Energy | Steepest descent | Conjugate gradient | BFGS | Simplex | GA | ||||||
Niter | Emin | Niter | Emin | Niter | Emin | Niter | Emin | Niter | Emin | |||
raloxifene | sp4 | 121.08 | 20 | 86.72 | 1600 | 66.71 | 1500 | 75.89 | 80 | 102.24 | 300 | 69.97 |
sp5 | 117.41 | 20 | 88.46 | 1000 | 71.65 | 1200 | 77.62 | 100 | 107.03 | 300 | 70.89 | |
RMSD | 0.01 | 1.23 | 0.05 | 0.14 | 0.42 | |||||||
FDI | sp4 | 119.61 | 30 | 74.02 | 200 | 66.14 | 1200 | 64.38 | 10 | 268.07 | 300 | 48.95 |
sp5 | 116.89 | 30 | 75.48 | 300 | 67.94 | 1000 | 67.96 | 10 | 283.08 | 200 | 51.83 | |
RMSD | 0.01 | 0.12 | 0.02 | 0.14 | 1.14 | |||||||
thymidine | sp4 | 99.64 | 30 | 64.82 | 400 | 60.52 | 500 | 61.17 | 20 | 114.81 | 300 | 61.40 |
sp5 | 95.78 | 20 | 68.49 | 200 | 64.29 | 1000 | 64.57 | 10 | 99.78 | 200 | 65.85 | |
RMSD | 0.01 | 0.09 | 0.03 | 0.06 | 0.63 | |||||||
PR2 | sp4 | 156.55 | 50 | -5.22 | 300 | -14.57 | 700 | -13.58 | 10 | 78.01 | 200 | -5.77 |
sp5 | 155.04 | 50 | 1.11 | 300 | -13.01 | 600 | -11.77 | 20 | 72.18 | 200 | -12.73 | |
RMSD | 0.07 | 0.02 | 0.01 | 0.02 | 0.61 |
The number of iterations needed to reach convergence (Niter) and the minimized energy (Emin in kcal/mol) and the RMSD values (in Å) between the optimized structures with sp4 and sp5 force fields are given.